The PSA All-Time Baseball Dream Team

Number of
Required Items
12
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
10.663

In the summer of 2015, PSA’s Joe Orlando put together his own All-Time Baseball Dream Team for a winner-take-all, single-game scenario. The lineup was compiled after considering all the legends of the game at their very best or in their prime. With so many great players to choose from, at every position, the decision-making process was excruciating and fun at the same time. After selecting the players Orlando felt were best for his ultimate lineup, he also chose the card that he felt best represented each icon. From Babe Ruth to Willie Mays to Mariano Rivera, Orlando’s team covers every decade from the 1910s to the 2000s. Some of the most popular baseball cards ever made can be found on this exclusive list, including the 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle. While there is no right or wrong answer when it comes to building your own Dream Team, this is one take on assembling a fantasy lineup for the ages. To read the full, in-depth article, click here.

All-Time Finest

Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses
Set Rating User
1 The Hill Collection 91.67% 8.21 R 8.29 7.61
2 Dan’s Baseball Dream Team Collection 91.67% 7.28 R 7.37 5.87
dan
3 rosie's PSA Dream Team 83.33% 5.65 5.65 3.46
4 Chris Bourne 58.33% 7.12 7.24 3.10
5 Jhurtiii 66.67% 5.86 5.96 3.04

View entire all-time finest list ›

Current Finest

Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses
Set Rating User
1 rosie's PSA Dream Team 83.33% 5.65 5.65 3.46
2 Chris Bourne 58.33% 7.12 7.24 3.10
3 Jhurtiii 66.67% 5.86 5.96 3.04
4 nutsonchin 66.67% 6.47 6.47 2.90
5 Doughboys 75.00% 5.37 5.37 2.85
6 TFJ's PSA All-Time Baseball Dream Team 41.67% 7.58 7.58 2.79
7 mcholke The PSA All-Time Baseball Dream Team 58.33% 8.25 8.47 2.77
8 Halbig Vintage Sportscards 58.33% 5.78 5.78 2.71
9 Dan32475 75.00% 4.96 5.04 2.67
10 Farlow126 66.67% 5.82 5.91 2.65
11 scarimbolod 58.33% 5.67 5.76 2.64
12 seasonticketholder... 58.33% 7.44 7.66 2.50
13 Maverick 66.67% 4.82 4.86 2.48
14 BuckSchott 58.33% 5.08 5.19 2.38
15 GP's PSA All-Time Baseball Dream Team 58.33% 6.92 7.05 2.30
16 Chris's Cards 58.33% 6.86 6.98 2.28
17 lrtsma 66.67% 4.82 4.91 2.20
18 rwatson328 58.33% 7.41 7.41 2.19
19 BigMike1979 50.00% 6.20 6.27 1.92
20 DrJimT2 41.67% 6.14 6.31 1.87

View entire current finest list ›