Sponsored Ads

All-Star Catchers (Carlton Fisk/Johnny Bench)

1974 Topps

Carlton Ernest Fisk (December 26, 1947-) was the first player in the win the American League Rookie of the Year Award by a unanimous vote after he hit .293 with 134 hits, 22 home runs and a league leading nine triples in 1972. He added a AL Gold Glove award that year as well. Pudge was a fixture behind the plate for 24 seasons with the Boston Red Sox (1969, 1971-1980) and the Chicago White Sox (1981-1993). At his retirement, he was the all-time leader in home runs by a catcher with 376 (since passed by Mike Piazza) and most games played at the catching position with 2,226 (since passed by Ivan Rodriguez. Fisk is renowned for his durability, strength and tenacity behind the plate garnering 11 All-Star selections and three Silver Slugger awards. A defining moment for Pudge and great moments in baseball history was his 12th inning home run in Game 6 of the 1975 World Series that he was seen waving fair as he made his way to first. The ball struck the left-field foul pole for a home run to win Game 6 over Cincinnati by a score of 7-6. Carlton Fisk retired with 2,356 hits, 1,276 runs, 376 home runs, 1,330 RBI and a .269 career batting average. Carlton Ernest Fisk was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2000.

Johnny Lee Bench (December 7, 1947-) is considered to be amongst the greatest catchers that Major League Baseball has ever seen and was the team leader that led the Cincinnati Reds "Big Red Machine" to back-to-back World Series titles in 1975 and 1976. Bench was a smart ballplayer, with an exceptional work ethic, who starred for his high school baseball and basketball teams and was named class valedictorian in his senior year. The Cincinnati Reds then took Johnny with the 36th overall pick of the 1965 MLB Amateur Draft. He spent two seasons with the Buffalo Bisons before getting the call-up to the big leagues. In 1968, Bench hit .275 with 15 home runs and 82 RBI to win the National League’s Rookie of the Year Award and his first All-Star selection while also posting a .991 fielding percentage and a 47% caught stealing percentage to win his first Rawlings Golden Glove. These accolades were early signs of what was to come. He won ten consecutive Gold Gloves behind the plate, second only to Ivan Rodriquez who won 13. In 1969, he set the single season caught stealing percentage record gunning down 57% of the opponent’s would-be base stealers and also posted a .992 fielding percentage. That same year, at the plate, Johnny led the NL with 45 home runs and 148 RBI while batting .293 to win the NL Most Valuable Player Award. Two years later, he would repeat as NL MVP, again leading the National League in home runs (40) and RBI (125) as well as throwing out 56% of the opposition’s base runners – second all-time in single season caught stealing percentage.

Bench led a host of All-Stars and future Hall of Famers like Pete Rose, Dave Concepcion, Ken Griffey, Tony Perez, Joe Morgan and George Foster during the 1970s, helping the Reds reach the World Series four times (1970, 1972, 1975, 1976). The potent, well-oiled offense of Cincinnati earned the moniker "Big Red Machine" and could beat you with power or manufacture runs. The Reds beat the Boston Red Sox four-games-to-three in what is considered one of the greatest World Series in history and then repeated as champions in 1976, sweeping the New York Yankees. The 14-time MLB All-Star was named the 1976 World Series MVP after batting .533 with two homers and six RBI in four games. Johnny Bench was the Cincinnati Reds catcher for 17 seasons (1967-1983) and was formidable hitter at the plate as he posted a .267 career batting average with 389 home runs and 1,376 RBI. Bench also finished his career with a .990 fielding percentage behind the plate, winning 10 Gold Gloves, and gunning down 44% of the would-be base stealers. Johnny Bench popularized the one-handed style of catching that is commonplace in the game today. Johnny Lee Bench was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1989. Since retiring, Bench has remained active in sports even attempting a run at the Senior PGA Tour after turning fifty. The Sporting News ranked him #16 on the "100 Greatest Baseball Players" list.

Condition Census

Pos Grade Thumbnail Pedigree and History
1 GEM MT 10
1 GEM MT 10
1 GEM MT 10
2 MINT 9 (64)

Prices By Grade

1974 TOPPS 331 ALL-STAR CATCHERS C.FISK/J.BENCH

Grade Most Recent Price Average Price PSA Price Population POP Higher
GEM - MT 10 $450.00 3
MINT 9 $178.50 $178.50 $50.00 64 3
NM - MT 8 $43.88 $38.93 $12.00 220 81
NM 7 $18.95 $5.00 97 312
EX - MT 6 $7.99 $7.99 41 414
EX 5 32 457
VG - EX 4 $0.99 $0.99 12 490
VG 3 10 503
GOOD 2 1 513
FR 1.5 514
PR 1 1 514
Auth 515

Auction Prices Realized

Date Price Grade Lot # Auction House Auction/Seller Type Cert
08/12/2022 $44 8 661 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 319 - Ends 8/11/22 Auction 14559664
01/31/2022 $40 8 275125122637 eBay d72hobby Auction 24601421
01/01/2022 $30 8 324962683672 eBay ryanm84_cards Auction 11565887
12/15/2021 $36 8 234323080281 eBay mustang67jim Auction 14965191
12/06/2021 $8 6 154724246651 eBay pk-cards Auction 43104507
11/01/2021 $179 9 265367880182 eBay 4_sharp_corners Auction 90643221
10/27/2021 $75 8 363587177712 eBay probstein123 Auction 90439815
10/22/2021 $45 8 384447501191 eBay probstein123 Auction 19664928
08/24/2021 $1 4 313641282953 eBay thowh347 Auction 42639563
11/30/2020 $30 8 303639140478 eBay kia102199 Best Offer 47331450
10/13/2020 $128 9 373251232492 eBay probstein123 Auction 48418662
09/11/2020 $15 8 193657144469 eBay curtisp14 Best Offer 60094527
08/04/2020 $30 8 143338634799 eBay nycsportscards Buy It Now 24601421
08/02/2020 $29 8 324209748684 eBay baseballfan10 Buy It Now 04601290
07/27/2020 $22 8 224063987888 eBay digdug08 Auction 24149410
07/13/2020 $10 6 143648287994 eBay monkeyclaus Auction 41542950
07/05/2020 $1 6 264779092939 eBay 515greg515 Auction 45992273
06/12/2020 $32 8 1711 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 264 - Ends 6/11/20 Auction 42795638
06/10/2020 $17 8 184316573995 eBay dpfeif01 Auction 23177940
05/17/2020 $21 8 264728176477 eBay sports-cards-forever Auction 30604843
05/15/2020 $19 8 133407339992 eBay robkas68 Best Offer 27425653
04/11/2020 $19 7 333563143477 eBay bigdavz Best Offer 17448017
02/20/2020 $14 8 202903113546 eBay steve_novella Auction 41103974
01/21/2020 $12 7 174153135589 eBay invalidliterde Best Offer 03534771
01/19/2020 $2 6 124045433792 eBay keithg0019 Auction 43104507
10/23/2019 $71 9 362783092418 eBay probstein123 Auction 16899984
08/08/2019 $118 9 123859986391 eBay mintandcentered Auction 42629552
07/30/2019 $50 9 183901920353 eBay abgb95 Auction 23280963
07/23/2019 $25 8 143328607301 eBay monkeyclaus Auction 41542949
07/22/2019 $15 8 383051414007 eBay probstein123 Auction 81832376
07/08/2019 $14 8 362688715505 eBay bbcexchange Auction 24601421
06/30/2019 $14 8 264373686636 eBay bleacher_bum Auction 27189371
06/25/2019 $14 8 283523054201 eBay nanoc433 Auction 24149410
06/10/2019 $15 8 1195 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 239 - Ends 6/6/19 Auction 42795638
05/20/2019 $46 8 233227202320 eBay dbredsox09 Auction 17991540
05/18/2019 $22 7 143255219697 eBay monkeyclaus Auction 42439321
05/14/2019 $58 9 143238508967 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 23280963
04/27/2019 $5 7 392280700001 eBay xvpnmc Auction 26466438
04/11/2019 $5 8 (OC) 312560627827 eBay mrdirt21 Auction 14456018
03/26/2019 $10 7 173814061224 eBay syaelbelle Buy It Now 41529724
03/15/2019 $80 9 362558960154 eBay doozie1967 Buy It Now 12223318
02/23/2019 $2 6 (ST) 132955800592 eBay mrbaseball_1 Auction 19421998
02/17/2019 $27 8 143121999519 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 23177940
02/12/2019 $3 6 264185153640 eBay kelbshere-0 Auction 27221585
02/09/2019 $19 8 273678734937 eBay d72hobby Auction 27425655
12/29/2018 $5 6 253981393196 eBay flsportscards82 Best Offer 27377234
09/03/2018 $13 8 113226098075 eBay keith6136 Auction 41103974
08/16/2018 $70 9 142896492666 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 17254978
08/12/2018 $11 8 183355435061 eBay chrisr-70 Auction 26819095
07/23/2018 $52 9 153105401846 eBay orangeroughy Auction 12223318
06/20/2018 $10 9 (OC) 132657851480 eBay jaybyrdie Buy It Now 31344985
06/19/2018 $73 9 362351798047 eBay probstein123 Auction 03777202
05/05/2018 $12 7 201960144532 eBay fritschcardsauctions Buy It Now 27189370
05/05/2018 $24 8 192428758270 eBay fritschcardsauctions Buy It Now 27189371
05/04/2018 $25 8 183177808564 eBay rudylane2911 Buy It Now 23833555
04/19/2018 $14 8 273139351778 eBay hk91308 Best Offer 26515223
04/14/2018 $19 8 142660657379 eBay bbcexchange Buy It Now 23278003
01/10/2018 $20 8 201960143435 eBay fritschcardsauctions Buy It Now 27189369
12/26/2017 $12 8 192404792299 eBay branoah0917 Buy It Now 27971191
11/07/2017 $10 8 391916530545 eBay mr-magazine Auction 27223815
10/10/2017 $2 6 182806081266 eBay ginger_kat_1 Auction 27674315
10/01/2017 $16 8 202060790744 eBay mrpr020103 Auction 15303510
09/10/2017 $5 7 362091184729 eBay jrm1967 Auction 27614270
08/15/2017 $65 9 192270919346 eBay branoah0917 Buy It Now 27494555
08/15/2017 $100 9 381941305038 eBay caljeff Buy It Now 23163119
08/15/2017 $181 9 352133815746 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 11523436
08/08/2017 $20 8 362034584306 eBay 4_sharp_corners Buy It Now 27425655
06/20/2017 $49 9 263036456609 eBay sports-cards-forever Auction 90129898
05/21/2017 $2 4 132189041418 eBay majordavesattic Auction 27046352
12/10/2016 $6 7 142200211919 eBay rkeimel Auction 17947194
11/20/2016 $60 9 222311398522 eBay ycbs Auction 15298265
08/22/2015 $48 9 84492 Heritage Auctions 2015 August 20 - 22 The 1970s Topps PSA Set Reg... Auction 18955323
Sponsored Ads