Sponsored Ads

Mickey Mantle

1953 Stahl-Meyer Franks

This is one of Mickey Mantle's most elusive cards, and it resides in one of the key regional issues of the era. In 1953, this New York-based meat company decided to issue one of nine cards into packages of their hot dogs. In their first trading set, they chose to manufacture three cards from each of the three New York area teams: the Dodgers, Giants and Yankees. Stahl-Meyer, who issued three different trading cards sets from 1953-1955, included some of the brightest stars from each of those teams, such as Duke Snider and Monte Irvin, but none of those stars shined brighter than Mickey Mantle, the key to the inaugural issue. These white-bordered cards, which measure approximately 3 ¼" by 4 ½" in size, were cut with diagonal corners, and the fronts were designed with a wax coating. In addition, these cards are not only very difficult to locate, but are extremely condition sensitive. This Mantle card is rarely seen and it remains one of the missing links to collections based on the Yankee legend.

Mickey Charles Mantle (October 20, 1931 - August 13, 1995), like his predecessor in the New York Yankees centerfield, Joe DiMaggio, became one of the most popular figures in sports history both during and after his playing career. Raised in Oklahoma, Mickey was the son of Mutt Mantle, a lead miner and former minor league player in his own right, who reared him to be a big league player and taught The Mick how to bat from both sides of the plate in anticipation of manager options as relievers were becoming more prevalent. As a teenager, his baseball career, and potentially his life was nearly ended when he suffered a injury that turned into a severe infection on the football field in high school. When a Yankees scout came to see one of Mantle's teammate's Mickey hit three home runs in the game and wowed fans and the scout alike. The New York Yankees signed Mickey a year later after his high school graduation and assigned him to the minor leagues. Mantle's meteoric rise through the ranks of the New York farm system compounded by the press' coverage of the young phenom who the dubbed to become the "next" Yankees star. He was originally assigned the number "6" to follow Babe Ruth's #3, Lou Gehrig's #4 and teammate Joe DiMaggio's #5. And, to add to the extraordinary pressure, DiMaggio announced his retirement at the conclusion of the 1951 season, Mickey's rookie campaign.

The Yankees sent the young phenom to the Kansas City Blues, but after only 40 games with the club was called up to New York for the stretch run as the Yankees ran away with the American League pennant. Facing the New York Giants in the World Series, Mantle suffered a severe knee injury, potentially a torn ACL, in Game 2 chasing down a fly ball off the bat of fellow rookie Willie Mays. The injury would nag him for the duration of his career. At the end of the season, Mickey moved over to the vacated centerfield, as Joltin' Joe DiMaggio entered retirement, and remained there for the majority of his career. In his first five seasons in New York, Mickey averaged 144 hits, 24 home runs and 89 RBI and starting in 1952, earned his first of 20 All-Star selections. In 1956, Mantle had a career year led the AL in batting average (.353), home runs (52) and RBI (130) to win the elusive Triple Crown as well as the American League Most Valuable Player award. He won his second consecutive AL MVP award in 1957 as he batted .365 with 173 hits, 34 home runs and 94 RBI as well as a league-leading 121 runs scored and 146 walks. He won a third AL MVP award in 1962. During what many refer to as the Golden Age of baseball; more young boys idolized The Mick than any other player of the era. Mantle showcased an unprecedented combination of speed and power and his tape-measure home runs thrilled fans for nearly two decades (1951-1969). He also led the Bronx Bombers to seven World Series titles during this span as he set the World Series all-time record for most career home runs with 18, most runs scored (42), RBI (40), walks (43), extra base hits (26) and total bases (123).

In 1959, the Yankee acquired the power-hitting right fielder Roger Maris from the Kansas City Athletics and the two became fast friends, earning the nickname the "M&M Boys." In 1961, Mantle and Maris captivated the American people as they began an assault on Babe Ruth's record 60 home runs in a single season. Mantle was unfortunately struck down my infection during the race for Ruth's record and finished the season with 54 dingers while Roger Maris topped The Babe on the final day of the season in Boston. But, during the chase, just as Mantle had experienced in New York after replacing the beloved Yankee Clipper, Maris struggled with the press and was portrayed as surly and "not a true Yankee" as many believed Mantle should have been the one to top Ruth's record. However, Mantle stood by Maris and helped him through all of the unwarranted criticism. Mickey played 18 years with the New York Yankees and lived a hard life of partying and carousing, not wanting to miss out on anything as he assumed he would suffer an early demise just as his father had and his grandfather before him. Though his career was riddled with injuries that kept The Mick out of the lineup far too often, Mantle finished his playing career with a .298 batting average, 2,415 hits including 536 home runs and drove in 1,509 RBI.

Following his playing career, Mickey suffered through a handful of bad investments including the failed Mickey Mantle's Country Cookin' chain of restaurants during the 1970s, but he did enjoy the success of Mickey Mantle's Restaurant & Sports Bar across from Central Park in Midtown Manhattan. The 1980s also ushered in a new era for the sports collectibles and memorabilia market, and few were a bigger draw than Mickey himself. He was unquestionable the biggest draw in the industry up until his death and he frequently insisted that lesser-known former teammates accompany him so that they too could capitalize on the recent boom. Mantle's hard living eventually caught up to him as he underwent treatment for alcoholism an eventually required a liver transplant. Unfortunately, only three months after his transplant, Mickey Mantle died on August 13, 1995. In 1969, the Yankees retire his number "7" and in 1974, he was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, but for the remainder of the 1995 season the New York Yankees worn black armbands with his "7" above them in memory of their fallen comrade. Mickey Mantle remains one of the most beloved Yankees in the history of the franchise and is memorialized in Yankee Stadium's Monument Park with his plaque affectionately noting that he was "a great teammate." In 1998, The Sporting News named him to "Baseball's 100 Greatest Players" list and the following year, ESPN's SportsCentury series ranked him 37th of the "50 Greatest Athletes."

Condition Census

Pos Grade Thumbnail Pedigree and History
1 MINT 9
2 NM 7
3 EX-MT 6
3 EX-MT 6
4 VG-EX+ 4.5
5 VG-EX 4
6 GOOD+ 2.5
7 GOOD 2 (5)

Prices By Grade

1953 STAHL-MEYER FRANKS MICKEY MANTLE

Grade Most Recent Price Average Price PSA Price Population POP Higher
GEM - MT 10
MINT 9 $85,000.00 1
NM - MT 8 $55,000.00 1
NM 7 $68,125.20 $35,000.00 1 1
EX - MT 6 $27,000.00 $22,000.00 2 2
EX 5 $15,000.00 4
VG - EX 4 $7,500.00 1 5
VG 3 $4,500.00 6
GOOD 2 $4,555.20 $2,700.00 4 8
FR 1.5 $5,500.00 2 15
PR 1 $3,533.00 $1,350.00 35 18
Auth 2 67

Auction Prices Realized

Date Price Grade Lot # Auction House Auction/Seller Type Cert
08/01/2023 $3,533 1 325740469632 eBay gmcards2 Auction 52409865
03/06/2023 $4,500 1 266150505936 eBay cccards Auction 67481008
02/21/2023 $5,120 1 364146407895 eBay probstein123 Auction 71493346
01/09/2023 $5,500 1.5 275610069658 eBay timl0987 Auction 68853786
08/15/2022 $3,480 1 995 Robert Edward Auctions 2022 Summer Auction 21002127
07/24/2022 $3,960 1 (MK) 50475 Heritage Auctions Summer Sports Catalog Auction Auction 19381833
04/19/2022 $3,250 1 154937586256 eBay pc_sportscards Auction 30137187
01/28/2022 $38,400 4.5 50635 Heritage Auctions Winter Sports Card Catalog Auction Auction 63212547
10/14/2021 $10,580 2.5 14 Clean Sweep Auctions October 14, 2021 Auction 20319271
08/16/2021 $3,358 1 353609238153 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 30296952
06/11/2021 $68,125 7 491 Memory Lane, Inc. Newman Auction Auction 11982481
12/08/2020 $3,190 1 284104181974 eBay prz289 Best Offer 17641902
05/11/2020 $2,640 1 55897 Heritage Auctions 2020 May 7 - 9 Spring Sports Collectibles Catalog Auction 45150477
02/10/2019 $1,327 1 (MK) 183672051894 eBay sniffy5 Auction 07128051
12/15/2018 $5,797 2.5 81 Memory Lane, Inc. Holy Grail Rarities Auction Auction 20319271
12/09/2018 $4,555 2 32 SCP Auctions Fall Premier Auction 2018 Auction 41590407
11/04/2018 $2,750 1 (MK) 132170580484 eBay www.707sportscards.com Best Offer 14550362
05/06/2018 $27,000 6 1281 Robert Edward Auctions 2018 Spring Auction 30674237
02/26/2018 $4,250 1 263519670786 eBay cardboardmemories2011 Best Offer 28617910
12/10/2017 $1,745 1 401451838411 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 27276044
08/12/2017 $1,968 1 (MK) 300 Love of the Game Auctions Fifth Anniversary Auction - Closes August 12, 2017 Auction 19237213
08/04/2017 $3,567 1 (MK) 9 Huggins and Scott Auctions August 2017 Auction Auction 27432494
07/09/2017 $2,425 1 352101394835 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 21379216
05/18/2017 $1,350 1 (MK) 172680379228 eBay vintageclassiccards Best Offer 07128051
05/09/2017 $1,497 1 (MK) 352043438949 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 11919435
01/29/2017 $3,369 1 110 Goldin Auctions Winter Auction 2017 Ending January 29 Auction 26579232
11/05/2016 $10,237 2 (MK) 802 Mile High Card Company November 2016 Auction 23451505
09/11/2016 $1,401 1 (MK) 142104856227 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 18785822
02/11/2016 $1,230 1 221 Huggins and Scott Auctions February 2016 Auction Auction 24935569
10/13/2015 $30,979 7 95 Mile High Card Company October 2015 Auction Auction 11982481
05/16/2015 $1,315 1 81423 Heritage Auctions 2015 May 14 - 16 Sports Collectibles Catalog Auc.. Auction 31692317
05/10/2015 $2,273 2 (MK) 594 Memory Lane, Inc. Spring Break 2015 Auction Auction 23451505
01/11/2015 $7,301 3 (MK) 525 Memory Lane, Inc. Past & Present Winter Auction Auction 23451507
01/11/2015 $1,708 2 (MK) 526 Memory Lane, Inc. Past & Present Winter Auction Auction 23451506
12/13/2013 $2,963 1 (MK) 478 SCP Auctions Fall Premier Auction 2013 Auction 22138680
02/03/2012 $2,091 1 149 Huggins and Scott Auctions February 2012 Auction Auction 19237214
10/21/2011 $2,670 1 402 Mile High Card Company October 2011 Auction 31692317
07/30/2010 $1,230 1 (MK) 446 Huggins and Scott Auctions July 2010 Auction Auction 14108831
09/30/2009 $2,214 1 (MK) 869 Huggins and Scott Auctions September 2009 Auction Auction 14108831
05/28/2009 $1,968 1 900 Huggins and Scott Auctions May 2009 Auction Auction 14108832
05/28/2009 $2,091 1 (MK) 58 Huggins and Scott Auctions May 2009 Auction Auction 14108830
Sponsored Ads