Carl Hubbell - 1933 Goudey

These are two key cards of baseball's first left-handed screwball specialist. Carl Hubbell was a very deceptive pitcher and his screwball was devastating at times. How devastating? In the 1934 All-Star Game, Hubbell struck out Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx, Al Simmons and Joe Cronin consecutively. Hubbell would also go on to win 253 games in his career, including five straight seasons of 20 or more from 1933-1937. Along the way, Hubbell would win two MVPs, once in 1933 when he went 23-12 with a 1.66 ERA, and again in 1936 when he went 26-6 with a 2.31 ERA. Unfortunately, Hubbell's specialty pitch did him in as he underwent surgery to repair his pitching elbow. He was never quite the same. The Goudey set features two different cards of the great pitcher, both exhibiting great eyeappeal. The #230 (Pitching Pose) card is considered the tougher of the two and is rarely seen in high-grade. Hubbell was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1947.

Carl Owen Hubbell (June 22, 1903 - November 21, 1988), along with Philadelphia Athletics and Boston Red Sox pitcher Lefty Grove, were in a league of their in the 1930s as Hubbell strung together five consecutive 20-win seasons, leading the National League three times while Grove led the American League four times in victories. Carl was born in rural Missouri, but then moved to Oklahoma where he graduated from Meeker High School before heading to the oil fields. Hubbell pitched for the company’s baseball team and was soon playing for Cushing in the Oklahoma State League. In 1925, Carl joined the Oklahoma City Indians of the Western League where he went 17-13 in his first season. This was where Carl developed his patented screwball, or reverse-curve (later referred to as the “fadeaway”), as he was trying to turn the ball over, giving it a sinking motion. The Detroit Tigers signed the talented left-hander in 1926, but with player/manager Ty Cobb refusing to allow Hubbell to throw the screwball for fear of arm soreness and damage, Carl was unable to find a roster spot with Detroit and was released. He signed with the Beamont Exporters of the Texas League and was then spotted by New York Giants scout Dick Kinsella, who reported back to manager John McGraw of his find and the Giants purchased Hubbell midseason in 1928. Over the second half of the season Carl went 10-6 in 20 games and 14 starts. While working to master the extremely difficult and physically grueling pitch, the screwball, which ultimately became his money or out pitch, Carl threw a no-hitter on May 8, 1929 against the Pittsburgh Pirates, though his teammates nearly gave it away with three errors and sloppy play behind him. As was customary for the giants at the time, Mel Ott led the offense with two home runs and three RBI in the 11-0 rout of the Buccos. After Bill Terry replaced Hall of Fame manager John McGraw in 1932, the Giants acquired catcher Gus Mancuso from the St. Louis Cardinals, setting up one of the game’s great batteries as Mancuso was particularly adept at catching low pitches framing them as strikes. If thrown correctly, the screwball off a left-handed pitcher curved low and away to right-handed batters. Hubbell himself later described it as “throwing it over the top with exactly the same motion as a fastball … but, it isn’t the break that fools the batter, it’s the change of speed. The couldn’t time it and were out in front of it.”

Hubbell was a key component to the Giants starting rotation that also included knuckleballer Freddie Fitzsimmons and the sinkerball hurling Hal Schumacher. By the early to mid-1930s, Hubbell was the premier pitcher in the National League and in 1933 he helped led the Giants to their first National League pennant in nine years. Carl went 23-12 that season, leading the league in wins (23), ERA (1.66), shutouts (10) and innings pitched (308.2). He finished second to St. Louis’ Dizzy Dean (199) in strikeouts with 156, but captured the NL MVP award. With the Meal Ticket, Hubbell’s nickname, leading the charge, the Giants beat the Washington Senators in five games in the 1933 World Series as Carl went 2-0 with two complete games and 15 Ks. Often remembered as Hubbell’s most astonishing feats, in the 1934 MLB All-Star Game, after allowing a single from Charlie Gehringer and then walking Heinie Manush, Carl sent down five of the greatest hitters the game has ever seen. With most of the American Leaguers unfamiliar with the screwball, he struck out Babe Ruth on five pitches, Lou Gehrig on four pitches, Jimmie Foxx on four pitched – though he alone made contact with a foul tip, and then Al Simmons and Joe Cronin to start the second inning. His record of five consecutive strikeouts to start an All-Star Game stood until the 50th Anniversary of the event when Fernando Valenzuela and Dwight Gooden fanned six in a row to start the 1984 All-Star Game. Also remarkable was the fact that all five of the batters were eventual Hall of Famers and some of the most feared hitter in history. Notably, after Cronin struck out, Bill Dickey lined a single to center and Hubbell came back to strike out his opponent, Lefty Gomez, to set the All-Star record of six strikeouts. Carl was a 9-time MLB All-Star.

King Carl pitched his entire career with the New York Giants (1928-1943) and led the National League three times in wins and ERA, twice in winning percentage and once in complete games, shutouts, innings pitched and saves. In 1936, Hubbell had a league leading 26 victories and 2.31 ERA to win his second NL MVP award. The 1936 campaign proved to be his best as he helped get the giants to the NL pennant, despite struggling mid-season. He won his final 16 starts including the pennant clincher. But, the powerful New York Yankees toppled the Giants in six games. In 1937, Hubbell remained focused and in control as he started the season 8-0 thus stringing together a 24-game winning streak that spanned the 1936 and 1937 season - the longest streak ever recorded in the American or National Leagues.. New York once again fell to the Yankees in the World Series that year though. Though arm soreness began to take effect on Hubbell over the remainder of his career, he was able to pitch a handful of gems, one-hitting the Dodgers on Memorial Day in 1940 and then one-hitting the Pirates on June of his final season. He also won eight straight games in 1942. Hubbell helped lead the New York Giants to three National League pennants and one World Series championship in 1933. With an arsenal of pitches anchored by a deadly screwball, Carl won 20 or more games in five consecutive seasons. Carl Hubbell retired with a 253-154 record, with 1,678 strikeouts and a 2.97 earned run average. He served as a scout for the Giants for 35 more years, even after the franchise relocated to San Francisco, though he remained on the East Coast. Carl Owen Hubbell was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1947. 



Condition Census (Explain)

Pos Grade Thumbnail Pedigree and History
1 MINT 9
1 MINT 9
2 NM-MT 8 (24)

PRICES BY GRADE

1933 GOUDEY 230 CARL HUBBELL

Grade Most Recent Price Average Price SMR Price Population POP Higher
Auth $113.50 $113.50 8 490
PR 1 $55.00 32 448
FR 1.5 $129.00 $103.50 13 432
GOOD 2 $169.99 $145.00 $100.00 53 363
VG 3 $202.22 $202.22 $165.00 66 277
VG - EX 4 $265.00 $254.14 $235.00 93 170
EX 5 $503.00 $380.00 $325.00 56 105
EX - MT 6 $585.00 $585.00 $475.00 37 60
NM 7 $990.00 $990.00 $800.00 25 29
NM - MT 8 $5,040.00 $5,040.00 $3,500.00 24 2
MINT 9 $15,000.00 2
GEM - MT 10

AUCTION PRICES REALIZED

Date Price Grade Lot # Auction House Auction/Seller Type Cert
05/24/2020 $129 1.5 233571329826 eBay stclaircards Best Offer 44921914
05/22/2020 $265 4 373052434047 eBay probstein123 Auction 28500317
05/14/2020 $170 2 153616695524 eBay peekenterprises Best Offer 42487224
05/13/2020 $335 4 353067049782 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 50042577
04/18/2020 $260 4 223973802986 eBay gordysrarecoin Auction 19368178
04/07/2020 $100 1 (MK) 402209763671 eBay ltdsports Buy It Now 44306343
02/29/2020 $256 4 164093126839 eBay fwfslf6 Auction 08208456
02/11/2020 $503 5 352956888327 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 44847407
01/14/2020 $275 4 324032436425 eBay gmcards2 Auction 28500317
01/06/2020 $78 1.5 362867017955 eBay probstein123 Auction 44170376
01/06/2020 $120 2 41045 Heritage Auctions Sunday Sports Collectibles Weekly Online Auction Auction 45032482
01/02/2020 $248 4 114033716558 eBay robrob-84jnm Auction 04610904
12/09/2019 $990 7 936 Robert Edward Auctions 2019 Fall Auction 04025339
11/12/2019 $257 5 559 SCP Auctions Mid Summer Classic Auction 2016 Auction 25701985
10/21/2019 $202 3 362778854264 eBay probstein123 Auction 27060910
10/14/2019 $223 4 383198352822 eBay probstein123 Auction 28500317
09/26/2019 $227 4 372776367425 eBay probstein123 Auction 43047714
09/04/2019 $220 3.5 401864072077 eBay teri781 Auction 43543648
08/15/2019 $249 4 372734342221 eBay probstein123 Auction 15387528
08/12/2019 $200 2.5 153497025320 eBay peekenterprises Best Offer 22825965
06/05/2019 $131 2.5 123787882437 eBay burkey9 Auction 42360062
05/19/2019 $175 2.5 113615851929 eBay benb51 Buy It Now 42360062
05/12/2019 $99 2 333173391661 eBay b-e-collectibles Auction 42543580
04/14/2019 $79 3 (MK) 352638924718 eBay just_collect Auction 42844467
04/07/2019 $134 2.5 133008962164 eBay natester1 Auction 17268098
02/11/2019 $585 6 352584104006 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 04089296
01/24/2019 $5,040 8 50230 Heritage Auctions 1933 Goudey Ended Jan 24th Auction 05007630
12/27/2018 $100 2 (MK) 192745176022 eBay dacubbiefan Buy It Now 17270516
12/07/2018 $3,080 8 86 Mile High Card Company December 2018 Auction Auction 07109292
08/05/2018 $200 4 302821852510 eBay magicbus43 Auction 41449972
07/21/2018 $80 2 112988497303 eBay pamsvintagegradedcards Best Offer 31527794
07/16/2018 $1,500 6 142847462369 eBay triplesssinc Buy It Now 29085415
07/15/2018 $180 3 142837846503 eBay davidbvintage Buy It Now 30658452
07/11/2018 $145 3 132672026727 eBay skipscards56 Best Offer 40711188
07/08/2018 $990 5 401559621049 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 08201097
07/07/2018 $220 4 153081654863 eBay glimpse.of.the.past Best Offer 07250484
05/29/2018 $73 2 382469694739 eBay probstein123 Auction 29039968
05/27/2018 $193 3 253636220016 eBay superdave Auction 40691385
05/14/2018 $480 6 372299662907 eBay probstein123 Auction 90355352
05/04/2018 $185 4 (MC) 362298112752 eBay b-e-collectibles Buy It Now 28533347
04/14/2018 $256 4 132568896675 eBay gregmorriscards Auction 15583293
04/10/2018 $280 5 401515701474 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 24134091
03/31/2018 $249 4 152957761604 eBay crafts1910 Auction 07250484
03/25/2018 $492 6 665 Love of the Game Auctions Spring, 2018 Auction Auction 90355352
03/18/2018 $277 5 332585215921 eBay buckswin07 Auction 30444960
02/12/2018 $251 4 382369992120 eBay probstein123 Auction 28343200
02/07/2018 $165 3 173143607849 eBay cooperstownsportscards Buy It Now 28668560
01/27/2018 $114 Auth 253381145200 eBay dwh200 Auction 28335743
01/16/2018 $248 3.5 372189537979 eBay probstein123 Auction 28549509
01/13/2018 $3,421 8 358 Memory Lane, Inc. Historical Rarities Winter Auction Auction 90354842
01/01/2018 $257 5 559 SCP Auctions Mid Summer Classic Auction 2016 Auction 25701985
12/31/2017 $119 2.5 232607836027 eBay kityoungcards Buy It Now 27860206
12/06/2017 $518 6 391939591492 eBay oldhousenextdoor Buy It Now 28183722
12/05/2017 $325 4 253283040628 eBay skess10 Auction 28343200
11/26/2017 $93 4 (MK) 332455697888 eBay just_collect Auction 28249060
11/24/2017 $270 4 322819892400 eBay strssrelief Best Offer 22663340
11/06/2017 $85 2 332435318533 eBay jcvintagesportscards Buy It Now 17130200
10/27/2017 $600 6 202074095842 eBay vintagescards Best Offer 14972769
09/24/2017 $310 5 382227499021 eBay probstein123 Auction 04680135
09/21/2017 $2,280 8 50230 Heritage Auctions September 2017 1933 Goudey PSA Auction Auction 19465518
09/14/2017 $59 1 (MK) 132329052833 eBay bbcexchange Buy It Now 27864863
08/27/2017 $461 6 222619461700 eBay the53kid Auction 14972769
07/21/2017 $560 6 192242182494 eBay deserticesportscom Best Offer 25375581
07/06/2017 $2,871 8 352098533350 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 02034329
07/01/2017 $300 4 142430369980 eBay amerlegends Buy It Now 27456417
05/28/2017 $48 1 361877933637 eBay fscards1 Buy It Now 28583105
05/01/2017 $169 3.5 361959955033 eBay probstein123 Auction 18800465
03/29/2017 $74 2 (MK) 401295874002 eBay kscards1 Auction 26611203
03/19/2017 $899 7 361925696991 eBay partnerone Auction 10958790
01/19/2017 $1,114 7 361878414821 eBay probstein123 Auction 26529895
01/17/2017 $76 1.5 302187256255 eBay carterscards2006 Auction 26671970
01/07/2017 $340 4 122292948934 eBay toywithus Auction 26696390
11/14/2016 $90 2.5 131986964624 eBay paulfd Auction 20888517
10/23/2016 $127 3 201689315472 eBay wandw-auctions Auction 26208506
10/16/2016 $485 6.5 361761587478 eBay partnerone Auction 15917317
10/12/2016 $327 5 351861693185 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 30444960
04/14/2016 $3,585 8 80230 Heritage Auctions April 14 2016 1933 Goudey PSA Set Registry Catal... Apr 14, 2016 Auction 19465518
08/15/2015 $510 6 380 Love of the Game Auctions Summer, 2015 Premier Auction - Closes August 8, 2015 Auction 40300222
03/20/2015 $3,361 8 61 Mile High Card Company March 2015 Auction Auction 01094678
08/21/2014 $109 2.5 25 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 114 - Ends 8/21 Auction 22947150
08/15/2014 $2,776 8 69 Mile High Card Company August 2014 Auction 31652856
04/11/2014 $2,472 8 534 Mile High Card Company April 2014 Auction 31652856
01/23/2014 $178 3 11 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 99 - Ends 1/23 Auction 06242796
12/06/2013 $420 6 147 Greg Bussineau Auctions Fall 2013 Vintage Trading Cards and Memorabilia Auction Auction 14918744
05/17/2013 $133 3 27 Sirius Sports Auctions Sirius Sports Cards Auction # 81 Auction 06242796
04/04/2013 $2,640 8 90 Greg Bussineau Auctions Spring 2013 Vintage Trading Cards and Memorabilia Auction Auction 05039819
07/20/2012 $3,556 8 364 Goodwin and Co. Auctions Masterpieces and Uncommon Commons XLII Auction 17338320
01/27/2012 $3,292 8 45 Mile High Card Company January 2012 Auction 17338320
09/22/2011 $238 4 497 Goodwin and Co. Auctions Masterpieces and Uncommon Commons XXXV Auction 30870719
09/04/2011 $102 3 41022 Heritage Auctions Sunday Internet Sports Collectibles Auction Sep 4, 2011 Auction 11469863
02/12/2011 $346 5 363 Goodwin and Co. Auctions Masterpieces and Uncommon Commons XXXI Auction 16689421
11/27/2010 $2,807 8 533 Mile High Card Company November 2010 Auction 03011197
03/26/2009 $905 7 397 Mile High Card Company March 2009 Auction Auction 16992310
03/26/2009 $560 7 396 Mile High Card Company March 2009 Auction Auction 05025525
12/16/2007 $1,622 7 253 Memory Lane, Inc. Serious Rarities - December 8th Auction Auction 04791653
01/28/2007 $135 3 12132 Heritage Auctions Monthly Internet Sports Auction Jan 28, 2007 Auction 06242796
08/12/2005 $5,283 8 117 Memory Lane, Inc. The Buried Treasure III Card & Ball Auction Auction 07002048