Eddie Collins - 1909 Philadelphia Caramel (E95)

Eddie Trowbridge Collins Sr. (1887-1951) was one of only a handful of Ivy League educated players in the Majors during his 25-year playing career, sparking resentment around the league among the less-learned men and even his teammates despite his tremendous success on the diamond. Eddie graduated from Columbia University, where he starred for the Lions’ baseball squad, but also quarterbacked the football team even though he only stood 5’9” tall. Collins skills were well known and he carried an air of self-confidence due to his abilities that may have gotten him barred from playing for Columbia during his senior season. In the collegiate baseball off-season, Eddie played semi-pro baseball for Plattsburgh, Rutland and Rockville under the assumed name Eddie T. Sullivan, at the advice of Philadelphia Athletics owner/manager Connie Mack. Unfortunately, when he returned to complete his studies and play for the Lions, he was deemed ineligible because of his affiliations with professional clubs and the fact that he accepted money for playing. He did, however, serve as coach. Eddie signed with the Philadelphia Athletics in 1906 debuting that same year in six games followed by 14 games in 1907. By 1908, having played five positions during his first two forays in the Majors, Collins nestled in at second base for the A’s and remained there for the majority of his 25-year career. Eddie Collins was one of the early students of the game who studied pitchers’ habits, like where and how they held the ball, where and what they were looking at and certain idiosyncratic movements the pitcher might make before, during and after his windup. Using this knowledge, he became the game’s premier base stealer, leading the American League four times in that category.

Nicknamed “Cocky”, Eddie was one of the best fielding second basemen that game had yet seen as he led all AL second baggers in fielding percentage nine times, putouts seven times, double plays five times and assists four times. He was unable to capture the American League batting title, given that he played during the same era as Ty Cobb with Cobb winning the crown 12 times and Collins finishing second three times and in the top ten 15 times. Eddie Collins was a centerpiece of the Athletics $100,000 infield, that also included Frank “Home Run” Baker (3B), Stuffy McInnis (1B) and Jack Barry (SS), and helped win four American League pennants and three World Series titles (1910, 1911, 1913) between 1910-1914. In 1914, Collins was crowned the American League’s Most Valuable Player after leading the league in runs scored (122), collected 181 hits drove in 85 RBI and stole 58 bases while posting a .970 fielding percentage. Despite his exceptional play at second, Connie Mack, in an effort to save his sinking franchise, sold Collins to the Chicago White Sox for $50,000.

He played in Philadelphia for nine seasons (1906-1914) and then the Chicago White Sox for 12 more (1915-1926). He helped lead the White Sox to the 1917 World Series title as he batted .409 with two RBI and three stolen bases. The team won a franchise record (at the time) 100 games, but virtually despised one another and more importantly owner, Charles Comiskey. Collins was then a member of the infamous “Black Sox” team who were charged with throwing the 1919 World Series, though he was deemed to be one of the nine players to have performed “honestly.” A handful of disgruntled players conspired with local gamblers to undermine the Fall Classic, throwing the World Series against the Cincinnati Reds. Collins admitted hearing rumblings that a “fix was in”, but he refused to believe it and after eight of his teammates were reprimanded, he was exonerated. Eddie later stated that the dissention in the clubhouse was palpable and “in 1919 we were a club that pulled apart rather than together” … despite being “the greatest collection of players ever assembled.” After serving as player manager from 1924-1926, Collins was dismissed and he resigned with Philadelphia for three more seasons (1928-1930). Eddie Collins finished his career with a .333 batting average, 3,315 hits, 1,821 runs scored, 1,300 RBI and 741 stolen bases. He also holds the Major League record with 512 career sacrifice hits. When his playing days were over, Eddie joined the Boston Red Sox as the Vice President and General Manager from 1933 to 1947. He embarked on one scouting trip to California during his tenure as GM and returned with two potential prospects in Bobby Doerr and Ted Williams. Edward Trowbridge Collins Sr. was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1939. 

Condition Census (Explain)

Pos Grade Thumbnail Pedigree and History
1 NM 7
1 NM 7
2 EX-MT 6
2 EX-MT 6
2 EX-MT 6
3 EX 5 (10)


Date Price Grade Lot # Auction House Auction/Seller Type Cert
11/07/2015 $4,302 7 10265 Heritage Auctions 2015 November 5 - 7 Sports Collectibles Catalog ... Nov 7, 2015 Auction 17817571
08/12/2017 $3,110 7 49 Memory Lane, Inc. Sizzling Summer Auction 2017 Auction 17817571
04/10/2018 $2,701 7 401515691685 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 40006161
05/16/2015 $1,912 6 80226 Heritage Auctions 2015 May 14 - 16 Sports Collectibles Catalog Auc... May 16, 2015 Auction 02072581
07/08/2018 $454 4.5 142847760034 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 15461298
05/18/2008 $389 4 165 Memory Lane, Inc. Spring Fever Rarities Auction 40230372
12/18/2011 $293 4 100 Memory Lane, Inc. Winter 2011 Auction 17920683
01/11/2015 $318 4 412 Memory Lane, Inc. Past & Present Winter Auction Auction 17920683
07/13/2017 $257 4 362030743342 eBay probstein123 Auction 11547746
09/01/2017 $350 4 253058252034 eBay mjhenr02 Buy It Now 11547746
06/14/2018 $407 4 382484564287 eBay probstein123 Auction 26884872
01/08/2012 $335 3 44002 Heritage Auctions Sunday Internet Sports Collectibles Auction Jan 8, 2012 Auction 19460299
12/07/2012 $180 3 24 Greg Bussineau Auctions Fall 2012 Vintage Trading Cards and Memorabilia Auction Auction 19460299
10/11/2016 $243 3 401198798314 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 17865508
12/04/2016 $288 3 401231301889 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 17865508
07/05/2017 $206 3 352097598125 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 27398963
08/15/2017 $118 2.5 302409056809 eBay carterscards2006 Auction 27653687
02/12/2018 $245 2.5 152905701223 eBay iconsportscards Best Offer 27653687
03/11/2018 $206 2.5 352294394093 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 28639763
11/08/2016 $158 2 142164474378 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 24526309
03/10/2017 $184 2 262874592519 eBay buddysbaseball Auction 22795043
06/21/2017 $128 2 132226796337 eBay scottdarlene Auction 24789173
11/12/2017 $155 2 142063390101 eBay fullcountcollections Best Offer 18601679
12/04/2018 $173 2 352525772405 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 17454531
04/11/2018 $95 1 (MK) 142748358569 eBay sewall Best Offer 27854903
08/26/2018 $72 1 123312974441 eBay memorylaneinc Auction 41278084
09/11/2018 $71 1 352435277897 eBay terrykcards Best Offer 25830408