Sports Market Report Online
Hall of Famers Game-Used Bats from the PSA SMR Price Guide. Articles, prices, and auctions for cards in the Hall of Famers set.

Game-Used Bat Values

Hall of Famers

Name
Approximate Value
Comment
Hank Aaron5000(1950s Hank Aaron bats are very tough)
  (a 1957 All-Star Hank Aaron bat sold for $21,300 in 2001)
  (a documented Hank Aaron HR bat #740 sold for $34,100 in 2004)
  (a documented 1956 Hank Aaron Adirondack bat sold for $14,300 in 2005)
  (a 1960 Hank Aaron All-Star bat sold for $25,200 in 2008)
Roberto Alomar475 
Cap Anson286800(only one documented Cap Anson bat - it sold in 2010)
Luis Aparicio2000 
Luke Appling3250 
Richie Ashburn4750(autographed Richie Ashburn bats sell for a premium)
Earl Averill6500(a vault marked 1934-35 Earl Averill bat sold for $8,250 in 2004)
Frank Baker12000(pre-1921 Frank Baker bats sell for $12,000 and up)
Dave Bancroft5000 
Ernie Banks6000(a 1958 Ernie Banks bat sold for $6,270 in 2010)
Johnny Bench2000(a PSA/DNA GU 10 Johnny Bench Bicentennial Bat sold for $7,312 in 2009)
  (a signed, PSA/DNA GU 9 Johnny Bench bat from 1973 sold for $3,049 in 2012)
Yogi Berra8000(pre-1960 Yogi Berra bats sell for a premium)
  (a signed 1951 All Star Yogi Berra bat sold for $32,312 in 2011)
  (a signed 1962 All Star Yogi Berra bat sold for $19,120 in 2012 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
  (a signed PSA/DNA GU 8.5 1961-63 Yogi Berra bat sold for $11,352 in 2012)
  (a signed 1951-52 Yogi Berra bat sold for $23,700 in 2013 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
Wade Boggs650 
Jim Bottomley6500 
Lou Boudreau4500 
Roger Bresnahan25000 
George Brett2500(Brett - heavily pine-tarred examples sell for a premium)
  (a 1977 All-Star Geroge Brett bat sold for $5,604)
Lou Brock3000(a Lou Brock rookie-era bat sold for $9,390 in 2002)
Roy Campanella15000(Roy Campanella bats are very tough)
  (a 1952 World Series Roy Campanella bat sold for $26,450 in 2009)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 9 1950s Roy Campanella bat sold for $21,330 in 2010)
Rod Carew600 
Max Carey5000 
Gary Carter450(a rookie-era Gary Carter bat sold for $1,500 in 2005)
Orlando Cepeda1300(early career Cepeda bats sell for a premium)
Frank Chance30000(a PSA/DNA GU 6 Frank Chance Spalding bat - one of two known at the time - sold for $31,070 in 2013)
Oscar Charleston50000 
Fred Clarke12000 
Roberto Clemente8000(grooving of barrel is sought after on Roberto Clemente bats)
  (a signed 65-68 Roberto Clemente/Forbes Final game bat sold for $38,187)
  (a signed 65-68 Roberto Clemente bat sold for $45,124 in 2005)
  (a circa 1955 "Momen" Clemente bat sold for $57,000 in 2007)
  (a 1960 Roberto Clemente bat, attributed to the World Series and graded PSA/DNA GU 10, sold for $41,825 in 2012)
  (a signed 1971 bat sold for $19,130, it was graded PSA/DNA GU 9.5)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 Roberto Clemente 1965-68 bat sold for $28,386 in 2014)
Ty Cobb65000(a superb 1924-28 Ty Cobb bat sold for $70,332 in 2003)
  (a 1922-25 Ty Cobb bat with provenance sold for $115,500 in 2004)
  (a 1925 Ty Cobb bat w/provenance sold for $74,917 in 2004)
  (a sidewritten Ty Cobb bat sold for $132,000 in 2004)
  (a 1919-1922 Ty Cobb bat w/provenance sold for $253,000 in 2012 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
Mickey Cochrane17500(a PSA/DNA GU 10 1933 Sidewritten Mickey Cochrane bat sold for $22,000 in 2009)
  (there are only two documented Cochrane bats known at this time)
Eddie Collins15000(a 1917-1921 Eddie Collins bat sold for $18,725 in 2001)
  (a 1923-25 Eddie Collins bat sold for $17,022 in 2004)
Earle Combs12000 
Stan Coveleski10000 
Sam Crawford10000 
Joe Cronin1200 
Kiki Cuyler4500 
Ray Dandridge3500 
Andre Dawson500 
Bill Dickey25000 
Joe DiMaggio22000(a 1950 World Series Joe DiMaggio bat sold for $81,900 in 2005)
  (a 1947 Joe DiMaggio bat sold for $73,000 in 2008)
  (a 1946-49 autographed Joe DiMaggio bat sold for $80,626 in 2010)
Larry Doby4500 
Bobby Doerr1500 
Leo Durocher8250(only one Leo Durocher bat known/this is the auction price)
John Evers20000 
Rick Ferrell3500 
Carlton Fisk550(A signed 1977-79 Carlton Fisk H&B bat sold for $2,500 in 2005)
Elmer Flick20000 
Nellie Fox1500 
Jimmie Foxx (1940's)18000(a 1920's Jimmie Foxx bat sold for $39,648 in 2002)
  (a 1926-31 Jimmie Foxx bat sold for $43,502 in 2006)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 1933 vault marked Jimmie Foxx sold for $68,000 in 2011)
Frankie Frisch5500 
Lou Gehrig97500(a sidewritten Lou Gehrig rookie bat (1923) sold for $125,000)
  (a 1932 signed Lou Gehrig World Series bat sold for $169,050)
  (a 1934-36 Lou Gehrig bat (Grove estate) sold for $156,000 in 2005)
  (a 1927 sidewritten Lou Gehrig bat sold for $184,236 in 2006)
  (a 1938-39 PSA/DNA GU 9 Lou Gehrig bat (Russell) sold for $403,664 in 2011)
  (a 1936-37 Lou Gehrig autographed bat graded PSA/DNA GU 8.5 sold for $292,775 in 2013)
Charlie Gehringer10000 
Joe Gordon5000 
Goose Goslin6500(early career Goose Goslin bats sell for a premium)
Hank Greenberg12500(early career Hank Greenberg bats sell for a premium)
Tony Gwynn850(a PSA/DNA GU 10, 1993-94 Tony Gwynn bat sold for $2,397 in 2014)
Chick Hafey5500 
Bucky Harris2000 
Gabby Hartnett10000 
Harry Heilmann5000 
Rickey Henderson575 
Billy Herman4500 
Harry Hooper15000(a vault marked 1911-15 Harry Hooper bat sold for $20,900 in 2004)
Rogers Hornsby13000(high-end Rogers Hornsby bats have sold for $25,000 and up)
  (a 1920's Rogers Hornsby bat sold for $29,078 in 2002)
  (an autographed Rogers Hornsby bat sold for $44,528 in 2003)
Monte Irvin7500(only a few Monte Irvin bats are known to exist)
Reggie Jackson1150(Yankee-era Jackson bats and early examples sell for a premium)
  (a rookie-era Reggie Jackson bat sold for $3,215 in 2004)
Travis Jackson6500 
Al Kaline1850(a 1966-68 signed PSA/DNA GU 10 Kaline bat sold for $5,603 in 2012)
Willie Keeler15000(a PSA/DNA GU 8, 1908-10 Willie Keeler bat sold for $19,120 in 2014)
George Kell1200 
George Kelly2500 
Harmon Killebrew5500(pre-1960 Harmon Killebrew bats are very tough)
  (a 1954 rookie Harmon Killebrew bat sold for $13,000 in 2005)
  (a 1970 All-Star Harmon Killebrew bat sold for $16,800 in 2005)
  (A 1969-72, PSA/DNA GU 10, Harmon Killebrew bat sold for $8,733 in 2013)
Ralph Kiner2500 
Chuck Klein6500(a 1934-43 Chuck Klein bat sold for $12,501 in 2002)
Nap Lajoie85000 
Barry Larkin475(a PSA/DNA GU 8.5, 1987-89 Larkin signed bat sold for $1,825 in 2014)
Tony Lazzeri10000(Yankee-era Lazzeri bats sell for a premium)
Fred Lindstrom6000(a 1933-34 Fred Lindstrom bat sold for $6,167)
John "Pop" Lloyd17500 
Ernie Lombardi7500 
Al Lopez4500 
Ted Lyons6500 
Mickey Mantle20000(high-end Mickey Mantle bats sell for a major premium)
  (a 1950's signed Mickey Mantle bat sold for $48,048 in 2004))
  (a 1951 Mickey Mantle World Series bat sold for $111,551 in 2005)
  (a 1958 Mickey Mantle World Series bat sold for $85,903 in 2005 and $91,000 in 2008)
  (a 1966 PSA/DNA GU 10 Mickey Mantle bat sold for $57,000 in 2009)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 1960 Mickey Mantle World Series bat sold for $116,121 in 2011)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 signed 1961 Mickey Mantle All-Star bat sold for $116,130 in 2011)
Heinie Manush6000 
Rabbit Maranville7500 
Ed Mathews3500(pre-1960 Eddie Mathews bats are very desirable)
  (a 1961 Eddie Mathews HR bat sold for $13,559)
  (a 1965 Eddie Mathews HR bat sold for $17,603 in 2002)
  (a signed 1954-57 PSA/DNA GU 8.5 Eddie Mathews bat sold for $10,157 in 2011)
Willie Mays6500(a 1961-64 Willie Mays bat sold for $18,725)
  (a documented Willie Mays HR bat #620 sold for $37,400 in 2004)
  (a 1965 Willie Mays HR bat (#491) from the "Roseboro Game" sold for $55,000 in 2012 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
  (a 1969-72 Willie Mays bat sold for $17,925)
Bill Mazeroski2500(a 1966 Bill Mazeroski bat sold for $3,868)
  (a 1965-68 Bill Mazeroski bat sold for $2,922 in 2002)
Willie McCovey1500(a rookie-era Willie McCovey bat sold for $6,270 in 2002)
  (a 1969-72 PSA/DNA GU 9 Willie McCovery bat sold for $5,251 in 2007)
Joe Medwick5500 
Johnny Mize3500 
Paul Molitor 650 
Joe Morgan850(early Joe Morgan bats sell for a premium)
Eddie Murray800(a signed 1991 PSA/DNA GU 10 Eddie Murray bat sold for $6,725 in 2006)
Stan Musial5000(pre-1960 Stan Musial bats are very desirable)
  (a 1955 autographed Stan Musial All-Star HR bat sold for $42,517 in 2009)
Mel Ott27500(a side-written Mel Ott bat sold for $54,004)
  (a 1930's Mel Ott bat sold for $38,705 in 2004)
  (a 1937 Mel Ott bat sold for $56,671 in 2005)
  (a 1930's Mel Ott bat sold for $48,300 in 2012)
Tony Perez550 
Kirby Puckett650(autographed Kirby Puckett bats sell for a premium)
Hal "Pee Wee" Reese4500(a 1952 Pee Wee Reese World Series bat sold for $17,603 in 2001)
  (a rookie-era Pee Wee Reese bat sold for $6,412 in 2002)
  (a 1955 Pee Wee Reese World Series bat sold for $8,733 in 2002)
  (a signed 1950's Pee Wee Reese bat sold for $6,559 in 2003)
Jim Rice750 
Sam Rice7500(a sidewritten 1928 Sam Rice bat sold for $16,500 in 2004)
Cal Ripken2000(early career Cal Ripken bats sell for a premium)
Phil Rizzuto9000(a PSA/DNA GU 8, 1950 Phil Rizzuto bat sold for $17,925 in 2014)
Brooks Robinson2000(early Brooks Robinson bats sell for a premium)
Frank Robinson2200(a signed 1962 Frank Robinson All-Star bat sold for $7,508 in 2001)
  (a signed 1966 PSA/DNA GU 9.5 Frank Robinson bat sold for $10,755 in 2011)
Jackie Robinson87500(an autographed 1955 Jackie Robinson bat sold for $85,000 in 2005)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 1949 Jackie Robinson All-Star bat sold for $132,000 in 2006)
  (a 1956 Jackie Robinson bat, graded PSA/DNA GU 10, sold for $83,650 in 2012)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 9 Jackie Robinson bat sold for $159,867 in 2013)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 9 1949 Jackie Robinson bat sold for $183,500 in 2013)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10 1955-56 Jackie Robinson bat sold for $162,267 in 2014)
Edd Roush1500 
Babe Ruth90000(a 1923 Babe Ruth signed/HR bat sold for $1,265,000 in 2004)
  (high-end and early Babe Ruth bats sell for $150,000 and up)
  (a 1924 Babe Ruth signed/HR bat sold for $225,000)
  (a 1929 Babe Ruth side-written/HR notch bat sold for $320,000)
  (a 1920 Babe Ruth PSA/DNA GU 10 signed bat sold for $233,160 in 2005)
  (a 1924-28 Babe Ruth vault marked bat sold for $591,007 in 2012 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
  (a 1927 Babe Ruth bat, graded PSA/DNA GU 10, sold for $388,375 in 2012)
  (a PSA /DNA GU 10 1924 Babe Ruth signed bat (Donahue) sold for $253,000 in 2012)
Ryne Sandberg750(a PSA/DNA GU 9, 1990 Ryne Sandberg signed bat sold for $1,798 in 2014)
Ron Santo 1750 
Ray Schalk6000 
Mike Schmidt1400(Mike Schmidt home run bats sell in the $3,500-$6,000 range)
Red Schoendienst850 
Joe Sewell5500(a 1923-25 Joe Sewell bat sold for $5,244 in 2002)
Al Simmons6500(a 1940 Al Simmons sidewritten bat sold for $9,607 in 2003)
  (a 1939-40 Al Simmons sidewritten and vault-marked bat sold for $15,474 in 2004)
George Sisler5000A 1916-21 George Sisler PSA/DNA GU 10 (257th Hit Bat) sold for $152,647 in 2010
Enos Slaughter2500 
Ozzie Smith750(a PSA/DNA GU 10 Ozzie Smith bat from 1978 sold for $2,052 in 2012)
Duke Snider12000(pre-1960 Duke Snider bats are very desirable)
  (look for evidence of handle tape)
  (a signed 1950's Duke Snider bat with tape sold for $18,751 in 2003)
Tris Speaker18500(a PSA/DNA GU 10 1928 Tris Speaker vault-marked bat sold for $34,846 in 2006)
Willie Stargell2000A PSA/DNA GU 9.5 Willie Stargell 1969-1972 bat sold for $5,036 in 2012
Casey Stengel15000 
Bill Terry15000(a 1934-43 Bill Terry bat sold for $6,345 in 2003)
Frank Thomas550 
Joe Tinker38,837(a PSA/DNA GU 10, 1910 Joe Tinker valut marker and side-written bat sold for $38,837 in 2014)
Pie Traynor6000 
Arky Vaughan6500 
Honus Wagner90000(a PSA/DNA GU 9 1914-15 Honus Wagner bat sold for $89,625 in 2011)
Bobby Wallace15000 
Lloyd Waner10000 
Paul Waner10000(early Paul Waner bats may sell for $10,000+)
Zack Wheat9500 
Billy Williams1200 
Ted Williams18000(a 1948 Ted Williams vault marked bat sold for $58,139 in 2002)
  (a 1955 Ted Williams All-Star bat (Milwaukee) sold for $72,000)
  (a 1955 PSA/DNA GU 10 Ted Williams bat sold for $30,434 in 2008)
  (Ted Williams' 400th Home Run bat sold for $102,294 in 2007 and $125,000 in 2011 - it was graded PSA/DNA GU 10)
  (a 1947 Ted Williams signed/vault marked example sold for $77,675 in 2011
  (a 1960 Ted Williams All-Star bat sold for $80,500 in 2012)
Hack Wilson8500(a 1932 Hack Wilson bat sold for $21,300 in 2002)
Dave Winfield600(Yankee-era Dave Winfield bats sell for a premium)
  (a PSA/DNA GU 10, 1985 Dave Winfield signed bat sold for $1,485 in 2014)
Carl Yastrzemski1500(a signed 1967 Carl Yastrzemski World Series bat sold for $16,100 in 2012)
Ross Youngs9000(a vault marked 1911-16 Ross Youngs bat sold for $12,100 in 2004)
Robin Yount650 

* Editor's note: plus (+) beside a price indicates that the price has increased in the past month. A minus (-) beside the price indicates that price has decreased in the past month.