The 2013 Baseball HOF Ballot Results
I will be the first one to admit that I am torn, like many others are, about the HOF voting process and how to treat players who rose to stardom during the so-called steroid era. That said, I was shocked that no one, not one player on the ballot, received enough votes to gain entry in 2013.
There are those who think that results like this are sending the correct message: that we shouldn't allow cheaters or those with questionable character into the Hall. Character certainly matters to me, but sorry, that ship sailed a long time ago... and so did the notion that no cheaters are allowed in the HOF. There are many players already enshrined in Cooperstown who I would never think of inviting to a family barbeque based on their lack of character. There are also more than a handful of HOF players who broke the rules during their careers.
There are others who argue that we should simply take the best players from any era, regardless of PED use, because the voting should consider context. In other words, we now know that a lot of players were taking PEDs during that time period, so if you take the best of the bunch, you would still be enshrining the best of a tainted group. At times, I find myself leaning towards this line of thinking, but then I am reminded of just how powerful these drugs are.
For those of you who think taking PEDs accounts for minor athletic improvement, think again. These kinds of drugs are far more powerful than most people realize. They can help turn average players into stars, stars into potential Hall of Famers and Hall of Famers into super-human beings. See Barry Bonds. I have seen what they can do from a distance and I have watched what they can do at close range. The transformation that can occur is frightening, and the results speak for themselves.
The problem is further complicated by the fact that some players have been caught; however, what about the players who were suspected but never caught? What about players that simply played during the period but were never suspected? No one would have thought that Rafael Palmeiro was taking them until he tested positive for one of the most powerful steroids known. He didn't look the part. Most people didn't realize that pitchers use PEDs too, mainly because most people have a stereotyped image of a steroid user stuck in their head – one that looks muscle-bound like Jose Canseco or Mark McGwire.
In 2013, no matter how you look at it, the all-time and single-season home run leader with the most MVPs ever (7) didn't make it. The pitcher who won 354 games with the most Cy Youngs (7) in baseball history didn't make it. The greatest hitting catcher of all-time didn't make it. Two 3,000-hit club members didn't make it. Four 500-home run club members didn't make it. Two 600-home run club members didn't make it. One 3,000-hit AND 500-home run club member didn't make it, along with several very good players, at least from a statistical perspective.
Some of the above were caught red-handed, some were simply suspected, some were not and absolutely none of them were voted in. I don't profess to have all the answers, but it is imperative that the HOF decides what the institution stands for after this year's voting. Our hobby is driven, in large part, by the creation of collection themes, and the HOF designation is one of the most important there is. I hope they can find a way to make sense out of a difficult situation, one that requires a defined goal and sensible criteria.
The fans and the hobby are waiting.
Never get cheated,
Editor In Chief
Copyright © 2015 PSA – A Division of Collectors Universe. Nasdaq: CLCT. All rights reserved.