1958 Topps - Master

Number of Required Items: 534
View Set Composition ( Shop )
Current Finest Possible Set Rating: 10.362

This is one of the tougher sets of the decade. The combination of the paper stock, inconsistent print quality and centering obstacles make this set a real chore in high-grade. In addition, the Yellow Letter subset, which appears in the first print run (1-110), is considered one of the most difficult subsets in the hobby. These variations that exhibit yellow lettering instead of the normal white, contain key players such as Hank Aaron and Roberto Clemente. These variations are very difficult to locate in high-grade. There are also several great combo cards, including a Mantle/Aaron World Series Foes card. This was the only card that the two sluggers ever appeared on together. The All-Star card run finishes out the set and many of these cards were unfortunately peppered with print defects. The key rookie in the set is the #47 Roger Maris card, a collector favorite. All in all, this is a very challenging set, even for the most advanced collector. For an in-depth article, click here.

Notes: This set is a work in progress. As new varieties are graded, they may be added to the set.

All-Time Finest
RankCollection% CompleteGPA WeightedGPA with Top Pop BonusesSet Rating
1 Williams Collection 100.00%8.93 9.81 09.81
2 Doyle Collection 100.00%8.86
Retired on 11/16/2015
Rank 1
Weighted GPA 9.632
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 9.632
9.63
09.63
3 Donald E. Spence - The Lone Star Collection Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.83 9.58 09.58
4 Hacnac Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.40 8.74 08.74
5 Phil Minard's - 1958 Topps Master Set 100.00%8.37
Retired on 8/22/2014
Rank 4
Weighted GPA 8.374
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.374
8.70
08.70
6 RKsFavoriteSet Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.00 8.05 08.05
7 Bob Anton's 1958 Topps Master Set 100.00%7.96 7.99 07.99
8 drbobtrefil 100.00%7.94 7.98 07.98
9 Jeffrey Lichtman 98.13%8.03
Retired on 9/4/2006
Rank 2
Weighted GPA 8.033
% Complete 98.13%
Set Rating 7.658
8.11
07.73
10 The Jim Capley 1958 Topps Master Set Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%7.68 7.68 07.68
11 bobsbbcards Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%7.60 7.60 07.60
12 Heritage Auctions - Fall 2015 99.44%7.66
Retired on 11/10/2015
Rank 12
Weighted GPA 7.665
% Complete 99.44%
Set Rating 7.571
7.66
07.57
13 The Steve Soloway Collection 99.63%7.50
Retired on 8/11/2011
Rank 10
Weighted GPA 7.503
% Complete 99.63%
Set Rating 7.450
7.52
07.46
14 Stevenson collection Click to Contact Owner 99.63%7.46 7.46 07.37
15 farfar's 1958 topps master Click to Contact Owner 99.81%7.39 7.39 07.32
16 D. L. Wilburn's 1958 Topps Master Set Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%7.21 7.22 07.22
17 Bill Dodge's 58 Master Set Click to view Set Images 94.76%7.83
Retired on 2/23/2009
Rank 5
Weighted GPA 7.831
% Complete 94.76%
Set Rating 7.109
7.85
07.13
18 Mets-71 90.07%8.05
Retired on 12/22/2010
Rank 10
Weighted GPA 8.046
% Complete 90.07%
Set Rating 7.008
8.09
07.05
19 ajg Click to Contact Owner 100.00%7.00 7.00 07.00
20 Bohica's 58's 98.50%7.18
Retired on 5/21/2008
Rank 5
Weighted GPA 7.181
% Complete 98.50%
Set Rating 6.988
7.18
06.99
21 GoldenEagle Click to Contact Owner 92.13%8.30 8.46 06.98
22 starfire030 Click to view Set Images 96.07%7.43
Retired on 5/6/2016
Rank 22
Weighted GPA 7.436
% Complete 96.07%
Set Rating 6.854
7.44
06.85
23 Tony's Master 58s Click to Contact Owner 93.82%7.75 7.76 06.74
24 gsande 99.81%6.61
Retired on 6/20/2014
Rank
Weighted GPA 6.605
% Complete 99.81%
Set Rating 6.543
6.61
06.54
25 Mike's Boyhood Heroes #1 94.19%7.32
Retired on 12/10/2008
Rank 10
Weighted GPA 7.320
% Complete 94.19%
Set Rating 6.402
7.32
06.40
26 Thom's 58 topps 91.95%7.34
Retired on 4/28/2005
Rank 5
Weighted GPA 7.338
% Complete 91.95%
Set Rating 6.147
7.34
06.15
27 diamondpaul48 Click to Contact Owner 83.71%7.98 7.98 05.95
28 jayandbutton Click to Contact Owner 92.51%6.82 6.82 05.70
29 BBCards4U Click to Contact Owner 73.22%8.39 8.68 05.61
30 Sully 98.13%5.61 5.62 05.40
31 Frankie's 58 Topps Click to Contact Owner 73.22%6.92 6.92 05.04
32 matrix's 1958 master Click to Contact Owner 61.80%6.78 6.80 03.89
33 Tucker's Best 56.55%7.34 7.34 03.79
34 MDC Collection Click to Contact Owner 56.55%7.54 7.54 03.74
35 Joseph J Lawlor Click to Contact Owner 66.29%7.17 7.17 03.70
36 JEM1958Master 38.76%6.19 6.19 03.44
37 Silent Partner 68.91%5.96 5.96 03.41
38 Brett's 58 Topps Click to Contact Owner 49.44%5.83 5.83 03.27
39 coachsnapps 31.65%8.08 8.24 03.27
40 Hamlet Prince of Denmark Click to view Set Images 32.21%6.99 6.99 03.22
41 1958 Topps Baseball rl Click to Contact Owner 51.87%7.01 7.01 03.21
42 1969cubfan 32.96%6.85 6.86 03.15
43 JR's '58 Master Set Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 59.74%5.51 5.52 03.03
44 Ric's Set That Everyone Hated Click to Contact Owner 52.43%7.57 7.57 03.01
45 zachpower04 51.69%7.00 7.00 02.80
46 Tom's 1958 Topps Baseball Click to Contact Owner 58.61%5.79 5.79 02.71
47 707sportscards LTD Click to Contact Owner 36.14%7.51 7.51 02.49
48 Boyds Toys Master 1958 Topps Set Click to Contact Owner 43.63%6.58 6.60 02.45
49 Dwyer's 1958 Baseball Click to Contact Owner 34.64%6.67 6.67 02.34
50 cmack Click to Contact Owner 32.96%7.98 8.04 02.28
51 Genghis34 Click to view Set Images 17.23%5.72 5.72 02.02
52 brendanschuster 35.77%5.14 5.14 01.85
53 Jeannie Dee Click to Contact Owner 24.53%6.56 6.56 01.84
54 dlaskd 25.84%7.11 7.11 01.82
55 A's Fan 25.84%6.27 6.27 01.79
56 Howards 1958 Topps - Master Click to Contact Owner 31.27%6.43 6.43 01.73
57 RG 58 collection Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 21.35%7.20 7.20 01.27
58 waynemartin Click to Contact Owner 18.73%7.45 7.46 01.02
59 NJYellowBrian Click to Contact Owner 14.42%8.22 8.30 00.93
60 NM58TBB 12.92%5.83 5.83 00.62
61 Senator 58 Topps Master 1.31%5.52 5.52 00.32
62 beedabee1 3.18%5.71 5.71 00.20
63 jbrownell Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 2.06%6.73 6.73 00.15
64 Bobby A Click to Contact Owner 3.00%7.44 7.44 00.14
65 Peytonwho Click to Contact Owner 0.94%4.56 4.56 00.13
66 1958 Topps Set A 0.75%6.46 6.46 00.09
67 jamroman 0.37%4.00 4.00 00.07
68 TA79Bandit Click to Contact Owner 0.19%2.00 2.00 00.01