1958 Topps - Basic

Number of Required Items: 494
View Set Composition ( Shop )
Current Finest Possible Set Rating: 10.387

This is one of the tougher sets of the decade. The combination of the paper stock, inconsistent print quality and centering obstacles make this set a real chore in high-grade. There are also several great combo cards, including a Mantle/Aaron World Series Foes card. This was the only card that the two sluggers ever appeared on together. The All-Star card run finishes out the set and many of these cards were unfortunately peppered with print defects. The key rookie in the set is the #47 Roger Maris card, a collector favorite. All in all, this is a very challenging set, even for the most advanced collector. For an in-depth article, click here.

All-Time Finest
RankCollection% CompleteGPA WeightedGPA with Top Pop BonusesSet Rating
1 L.R.'s 1958 Vintage Baseball 100.00%9.07
Retired on 3/9/2016
Rank 1
Weighted GPA 10.006
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 10.006
10.01
10.01
1 The Tull Collection 100.00%9.07 10.01 10.01
3 Williams Collection 100.00%9.02 9.88 09.88
4 Donald E. Spence - The Lone Star Collection Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.93 9.69 09.69
5 Doyle Collection 98.99%8.94
Retired on 5/27/2015
Rank 2
Weighted GPA 8.939
% Complete 98.99%
Set Rating 8.864
9.69
09.61
6 Hacnac Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.54 8.90 08.90
7 Heritage Auctions - April 2010 100.00%8.25
Retired on 5/4/2010
Rank 3
Weighted GPA 8.253
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.253
8.41
08.41
8 Herb Watson 100.00%8.25
Retired on 3/3/2010
Rank 3
Weighted GPA 8.250
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.250
8.41
08.41
9 The Duke of Mint 100.00%8.25
Retired on 8/16/2012
Rank 6
Weighted GPA 8.246
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.246
8.40
08.40
10 Ruby 100.00%8.16
Retired on 2/5/2004
Rank 1
Weighted GPA 8.162
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.162
8.29
08.29
11 chrisandfaith Click to Contact Owner 98.99%8.20 8.37 08.27
12 GoldenEagle Click to Contact Owner 98.99%8.30 8.45 08.25
13 Jeffrey Lichtman 100.00%8.08
Retired on 9/4/2006
Rank 3
Weighted GPA 8.080
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.080
8.14
08.14
14 Henri Nuber 1958 Collection Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%8.06 8.09 08.09
15 The Crandell Collection 100.00%8.03
Retired on 8/26/2016
Rank 15
Weighted GPA 8.061
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 8.061
8.06
08.06
16 Bob Anton's 1958 Topps Basic Set Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.00 8.01 08.01
17 z8888 Click to Contact Owner 100.00%8.00 8.01 08.01
18 Staffoli's 58 Baseball 100.00%8.00 8.00 08.00
19 DLA 1958 Topps 100.00%7.95
Retired on 10/21/2012
Rank 14
Weighted GPA 7.953
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.953
7.95
07.95
20 richenkel Click to Contact Owner 99.80%8.01 8.01 07.90
21 dglickfield 98.18%8.02
Retired on 8/18/2009
Rank 9
Weighted GPA 8.019
% Complete 98.18%
Set Rating 7.845
8.02
07.85
22 Chisoxmaven's 1958 Topps Click to Contact Owner 100.00%7.81 7.81 07.81
23 Tony's58s 100.00%7.80 7.80 07.80
24 Stevenson collection Click to Contact Owner 100.00%7.77 7.78 07.78
25 Bill Dodge's 58 Set Click to view Set Images 97.77%7.92
Retired on 2/23/2009
Rank 9
Weighted GPA 7.922
% Complete 97.77%
Set Rating 7.745
7.95
07.77
26 bobsbbcards Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%7.75 7.75 07.75
27 The Steve Soloway Collection 100.00%7.69
Retired on 8/11/2011
Rank 17
Weighted GPA 7.689
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.689
7.69
07.69
28 farfar's 1958 topps - basic Click to Contact Owner 100.00%7.55 7.55 07.55
29 1958 topps By Thom 100.00%7.50
Retired on 8/11/2009
Rank 12
Weighted GPA 7.502
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.502
7.51
07.51
30 Mets-71 92.71%8.05
Retired on 12/22/2010
Rank 18
Weighted GPA 8.049
% Complete 92.71%
Set Rating 7.415
8.07
07.44
31 palacejester 96.56%8.00
Retired on 7/4/2012
Rank 25
Weighted GPA 8.000
% Complete 96.56%
Set Rating 7.426
8.00
07.43
32 Legendary Auctions 100.00%7.37
Retired on 7/23/2010
Rank 19
Weighted GPA 7.371
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.371
7.37
07.37
33 Sppot Baseball Sets 100.00%7.36 7.36 07.36
34 EMO 1958 Topps Baseball Click to view Set Images 100.00%7.36
Retired on 6/9/2014
Rank 31
Weighted GPA 7.363
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.363
7.36
07.36
35 D. L. Wilburn's 1958 Topps Basic Set Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 100.00%7.33 7.34 07.34
36 The cards your mom said she threw out 1958 94.74%8.01 8.01 07.31
37 roce4e52 100.00%7.15 7.15 07.15
38 Super Bee Cards Click to view Set Images 100.00%7.15
Retired on 5/14/2006
Rank 6
Weighted GPA 7.146
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 7.146
7.15
07.15
39 johnc3514 100.00%7.13 7.13 07.13
40 diamondpaul48 91.70%8.00
Retired on 6/23/2016
Rank 36
Weighted GPA 8.003
% Complete 91.70%
Set Rating 7.116
8.00
07.12
41 Memories of 58 100.00%7.11 7.11 07.11
42 Mastro Auctions 93.72%7.58
Retired on 10/20/2006
Rank 8
Weighted GPA 7.581
% Complete 93.72%
Set Rating 7.068
7.58
07.07
43 Rivard Collection Click to Contact Owner 94.94%7.87 7.88 07.06
44 Kens Best Set 94.94%7.97
Retired on 5/31/2013
Rank 35
Weighted GPA 7.972
% Complete 94.94%
Set Rating 6.983
7.98
06.99
45 jayandbutton Click to Contact Owner 100.00%6.83 6.83 06.83
46 juaneppy 94.33%7.50 7.51 06.75
47 gsande 100.00%6.71
Retired on 6/20/2014
Rank 39
Weighted GPA 6.707
% Complete 100.00%
Set Rating 6.707
6.71
06.71
48 BBCards4U Click to Contact Owner 76.32%8.46 8.76 06.13
49 Sully 100.00%5.65 5.65 05.65
50 The Mueller 1958 Topps Baseball Collection 79.15%7.40 7.40 05.32
51 1958 Baby Boomer Folly Click to Contact Owner 75.10%8.00 8.00 05.24
52 mccordcf 58.91%8.03 8.04 04.71
53 Tucker's Best 60.93%7.35 7.35 04.49
54 MDC Collection Click to Contact Owner 61.34%7.54 7.54 04.43
55 Joseph J Lawlor Click to Contact Owner 70.04%7.19 7.19 04.26
56 matrix's 58 basic Click to Contact Owner 62.15%6.85 6.86 04.07
57 JEM1958 41.50%6.48 6.48 03.54
58 JR's 1st Topps 1958's Click to view Set Images 63.56%5.59 5.59 03.52
59 1958 Topps - Bob Hall Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 43.93%6.35 6.35 03.36
60 1969cubfan 33.20%7.18 7.19 03.30
61 Jim's 1958 Topps Work in Progress 54.45%4.64 4.64 02.93
62 The MDJ Baseball Collection Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 50.81%7.00 7.00 02.77
63 707sportscards LTD Lots of Color here Click to Contact Owner 36.84%7.61 7.62 02.70
64 Boyds Toys-58 Click to Contact Owner 46.15%6.65 6.65 02.68
65 cmack Click to Contact Owner 35.22%8.01 8.07 02.61
66 928s-4 Click to Contact Owner 45.55%5.53 5.53 02.29
67 hughandval97 37.04%8.04 8.06 02.28
68 brendanschuster 40.08%5.02 5.02 02.26
69 A's Fan - 1958 Topps- Basic 28.95%6.29 6.29 02.18
70 Howards 1958 Topps Click to Contact Owner 34.41%6.46 6.46 02.15
71 Linedrivehit Click to Contact Owner 28.74%6.54 6.57 02.11
72 Mile High Card Co. 2016 Fall Auction 34.01%8.00 8.00 02.00
73 mattyyy2002 18.83%6.20 6.20 01.92
74 1958 Topps Baseball Click to view Set Images 17.00%7.35 7.35 01.81
75 CharlieP 1958 Topps - Basic Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 30.16%7.04 7.04 01.73
76 Tory's 1958 Topps Basic Baseball Set 29.76%5.18 5.18 01.57
77 Southpaw's 58 Topps Set 16.60%6.64 6.64 01.50
78 PC58Topps 20.04%6.68 6.68 01.22
79 Hondo's 1958 Topps set Click to Contact Owner 19.03%7.00 7.00 01.19
80 Terry's 1958 Topps Click to Contact Owner 12.15%5.33 5.33 01.14
81 NJYellowBrian Click to Contact Owner 15.59%8.22 8.30 01.11
82 andrew120497 13.56%6.46 6.46 01.04
83 BloodDocs 1958 Topps 14.37%6.85 6.85 01.03
84 Dave Baskin Collection Click to view Set Images 16.80%6.73 6.73 01.02
85 cardyman Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 7.69%6.57 6.57 00.95
86 HardEight2013 Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 13.97%6.21 6.21 00.91
87 terrywking 9.72%7.56 7.56 00.83
88 Pmsbcc PSA Sets Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 9.11%7.81 7.82 00.81
89 bshillc50 Click to Contact Owner 12.15%5.25 5.25 00.76
90 RER3 Mixed Grades 10.53%4.61 4.61 00.76
91 perryt 5.87%5.60 5.60 00.64
92 Rsrhodessr 1958 Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 10.53%6.07 6.07 00.63
93 boberobinson Click to Contact Owner 10.53%5.20 5.20 00.62
94 BigBoy61 12.96%5.88 5.88 00.57
95 DLW's '58 Basic Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 6.68%7.62 7.62 00.53
96 markhj1111 Click to Contact Owner 3.85%7.80 7.80 00.53
97 Mark's 58's Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 6.28%8.02 8.02 00.49
98 CCC Click to Contact Owner 5.26%9.00 9.67 00.45
99 shocking 3.24%7.90 7.90 00.35
100 togh48831 Click to Contact Owner 5.47%6.63 6.63 00.31
101 George Divel's 1958 Topps - Basic Click to Contact Owner 4.05%9.00 9.64 00.30
102 [email protected] Click to view Set Images 2.23%7.02 7.02 00.24
103 natey777 1.01%8.00 8.00 00.23
104 jbrownell Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 2.23%6.73 6.73 00.17
105 Bobby A Click to Contact Owner 3.24%7.44 7.44 00.17
106 mikefromct 1958 Topps Baseball 2.63%6.71 6.71 00.16
107 JVH 1958 Click to Contact Owner 1.62%3.87 3.87 00.15
108 JM 1958 Topps 1.01%3.87 3.87 00.12
109 jcraighannon Click to Contact Owner 0.61%6.00 6.00 00.10
110 Nopamart 1.82%6.50 6.50 00.09
111 SixShooter Click to Contact Owner 0.40%6.37 6.37 00.08
112 abcsportscards 0.81%5.59 5.59 00.07
113 Leiva Collection 0.61%7.22 7.22 00.05
114 hodge91 0.81%5.78 5.78 00.04
115 drillin1350 0.40%2.67 2.67 00.03
116 GradedSports.com 1958 Topps Baseball Click to Contact Owner 0.40%8.50 9.00 00.03
117 Jackson Collection 0.20%8.00
Retired on 8/14/2006
Rank 28
Weighted GPA 8.000
% Complete 0.20%
Set Rating 0.017
8.00
00.02
118 gabr611 Click to Contact OwnerClick to view Set Images 0.20%7.00 7.00 00.01
119 TA79Bandit Click to Contact Owner 0.20%2.00 2.00 00.01