| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Dave B's - Staten Island Yankees
| 97.73% | 9.674 |
09.455
|
| 2 |
Lenhill Court Productions
| 97.73% | 9.419 |
09.205
|
| 3 |
Donald E. Spence - The Lone Star Collection
| 97.73% | 9.291 |
09.080
|
| 4 |
Capecards
| 97.73% | 9.256 |
09.045
|
| 5 |
BKH
| 100.00% | 8.605 |
08.605
|
| 6 |
The Crandell Collection
| 97.73% | 8.500 |
08.307
|
| 7 |
Nats fan's Yankees HOFers
| 95.45% | 8.560 |
08.170
|
| 8 |
(deleted set)
| 97.73% | 7.779 |
07.602
|
| 9 |
Frank Evanov
| 90.91% | 8.300 |
07.545
|
| 10 |
707sportscards LTD
| 93.18% | 7.890 |
07.352
|
| 11 |
Griffins
| 90.91% | 7.975 |
07.250
|
| 12 |
RJS Yanks
| 90.91% | 7.950 |
07.227
|
| 13 |
Marshall Fogel
| 81.82% | 8.472 |
06.932
|
| 14 |
The Crandell Collection
| 81.82% | 8.306 |
06.795
|
| 15 |
Paleocards - HOF Yankees
| 77.27% | 8.162 |
06.307
|
| 16 |
RayYankee's HOF Yankees
| 93.02% | 6.375 |
05.930
|
| 17 |
Tom V's HOF Yankees
| 95.45% | 5.988 |
05.716
|
| 18 |
NMHOFNYYBB
| 74.42% | 7.531 |
05.605
|
| 19 |
genf
| 62.79% | 7.981 |
05.012
|
| 20 |
Peltz22 Collection
| 54.55% | 8.625 |
04.705
|
| 21 |
GoSoxBoSox
| 88.37% | 5.184 |
04.581
|
| 22 |
The Conforti Collection
| 52.27% | 8.435 |
04.409
|
| 23 |
(deleted set)
| 38.64% | 9.647 |
03.727
|
| 24 |
(deleted set)
| 79.07% | 4.706 |
03.721
|
| 25 |
The Wydeven Collection
| 50.00% | 6.818 |
03.409
|
| 26 |
sdsportsfan
| 68.18% | 4.867 |
03.318
|
| 27 |
Cecil B's Hall of Fame New York Yankees
| 38.64% | 8.235 |
03.182
|
| 28 |
ShoelessJim's New York Yankees Hall of Famers
| 65.12% | 4.786 |
03.116
|
| 29 |
ajoy
| 53.49% | 5.478 |
02.930
|
| 30 |
(deleted set)
| 36.36% | 7.875 |
02.864
|
| 31 |
StrikeEmOut
| 38.64% | 7.176 |
02.773
|
| 32 |
gabr611
| 36.36% | 7.500 |
02.727
|
| 33 |
jbrownell
| 34.09% | 7.600 |
02.591
|
| 34 |
JBNY7'S HOF Yanks
| 32.56% | 7.500 |
02.442
|
| 35 |
TGF Collection
| 25.00% | 9.273 |
02.318
|
| 36 |
David Eloe
| 29.55% | 7.769 |
02.295
|
| 36 |
(deleted set)
| 34.09% | 6.333 |
02.159
|
| 37 |
jojowest
| 29.55% | 7.231 |
02.136
|
| 38 |
Russ' HOF Yankees Graded Set
| 34.88% | 5.600 |
01.953
|
| 39 |
Robert J. Utley
| 40.91% | 3.861 |
01.580
|
| 40 |
crf jvf svf
| 30.23% | 5.308 |
01.605
|
| 41 |
GotInk?
| 20.45% | 7.333 |
01.500
|
| 42 |
mpriest78
| 18.18% | 7.875 |
01.432
|
| 43 |
socaltiggurr
| 15.91% | 8.857 |
01.409
|
| 44 |
Jellybean Collection
| 18.18% | 7.625 |
01.386
|
| 45 |
Jed's HOF Bombers
| 20.45% | 6.667 |
01.364
|
| 46 |
lrtsma
| 22.73% | 5.650 |
01.284
|
| 47 |
KonradKuhn1
| 16.28% | 7.714 |
01.256
|
| 47 |
(deleted set)
| 13.64% | 7.750 |
01.057
|
| 49 |
rheck4
| 15.91% | 6.143 |
00.977
|
| 50 |
Michael Wachs
| 11.36% | 6.600 |
00.750
|
| 52 |
(deleted set)
| 09.09% | 7.250 |
00.659
|
| 52 |
Neil's Yankee Hall of Famers
| 06.82% | 9.667 |
00.659
|
| 53 |
(deleted set)
| 09.09% | 7.000 |
00.636
|
| 53 |
(deleted set)
| 09.09% | 7.000 |
00.636
|
| 55 |
(deleted set)
| 06.82% | 9.333 |
00.636
|
| 56 |
ronniekopetic's H.O.F yankees
| 06.82% | 7.333 |
00.500
|
| 57 |
(deleted set)
| 04.55% | 10.000 |
00.455
|
| 58 |
cooper1927
| 06.82% | 4.333 |
00.295
|
| 59 |
(deleted set)
| 04.55% | 6.000 |
00.273
|
| 60 |
(deleted set)
| 04.55% | 5.500 |
00.250
|
| 61 |
(deleted set)
| 02.33% | 6.000 |
00.140
|
| 62 |
(deleted set)
| 04.55% | 5.000 |
00.227
|
| 63 |
(deleted set)
| 02.27% | 10.000 |
00.227
|
| 64 |
(deleted set)
| 06.82% | 3.000 |
00.205
|
| 65 |
(deleted set)
| 02.27% | 8.000 |
00.182
|
| 66 |
(deleted set)
| 02.27% | 7.000 |
00.159
|