| Rank | Collection | Category | Composite | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 3 |
1940 World Series Champs Reds

| Baseball | 1940 Reds Harry Hartman (W711-2) | 100.00% |
7.78
|
07.78
|
| 1 |
Miracle Mets

| Baseball | 1969 Mets Team Issue | 100.00% |
8.88
|
08.88
|
| 84 |
Phil's '71 Topps

| Baseball | 1971 Topps | 52.13% |
7.97
|
04.53
|
| 1 |
Big Red Machine
 
| Baseball | 1975 Cincinnati Reds Team Issue Postcards | 93.75% |
6.43
|
06.03
|
| 1 |
Golden Sponge Cake '75

| Baseball | 1975 Hostess Hand Cut Panels | 88.00% |
9.43
|
08.69
|
| 6 |
Tony the Tiger '75

| Baseball | 1975 Kelloggs - Basic | 100.00% |
9.17
|
09.17
|
| 5 |
Tony the Tiger '75

| Baseball | 1975 Kelloggs - Master | 100.00% |
9.16
|
09.16
|
| 5 |
Golden Sponge Cake '76

| Baseball | 1976 Hostess Hand Cut Panels | 18.00% |
9.67
|
01.93
|
| 3 |
Golden Sponge Cake '77

| Baseball | 1977 Hostess Hand Cut Panels | 14.00% |
9.14
|
02.78
|
| 1 |
Peel Here '81

| Baseball | 1981 Fleer Star Stickers | 71.09% |
9.25
|
06.58
|
| 3 |
Phil's 1986 Fleer

| Baseball | 1986 Fleer | 4.09% |
10.00
|
00.41
|
| 1 |
Big Red Machine HOFers

| Baseball | 1992 Upper Deck Bench/Morgan Heroes | 90.91% |
10.00
|
09.09
|
| 21 |
Cooperstown Collection

| Baseball | Hall of Fame Players, Managers, Owners, Executives, Pioneers, Commissioners & Umpires Restricted Set | 38.40% |
8.17
|
03.14
|
| 4 |
Phil's Hall of Fame Reds

| Baseball | Cincinnati Reds Team Hall of Fame | 53.25% |
8.71
|
04.64
|
| 5 |
Phil's '71 HOF

| Baseball | 1971 Topps HOF | 94.44% |
7.94
|
07.73
|
| 3 |
Phil's #5 Basic

| Baseball | Johnny Bench Basic Set | 100.00% |
9.19
|
09.19
|
| 1 |
Phil's #5 Master

| Baseball | Johnny Bench Master Set | 94.34% |
8.51
|
07.76
|
| 4 |
Phil's #5 Basic Topps

| Baseball | Johnny Bench Basic Topps Set | 93.75% |
8.90
|
08.65
|
| 1 |
Phil's #5 Master Topps

| Baseball | Johnny Bench Master Topps Set | 96.34% |
8.79
|
08.35
|
| 2 |
Phil's Billingham Master
 
| Baseball | Jack Billingham Master Set | 58.33% |
8.69
|
05.13
|
| 2 |
Phil's Borbon Master

| Baseball | Pedro Borbon Master Set | 59.46% |
8.34
|
05.48
|
| 2 |
Phil's Carroll Master
 
| Baseball | Clay Carroll Master Set | 53.06% |
8.42
|
04.12
|
| 4 |
Phil's Concepcion Basic

| Baseball | Dave Concepcion Basic Set | 92.11% |
9.20
|
08.76
|
| 2 |
Phil's #13 Master

| Baseball | Dave Concepcion Master Set | 56.19% |
8.50
|
04.27
|
| 4 |
Phil's Foster Master

| Baseball | George Foster Master Set | 36.43% |
8.73
|
03.69
|
| 2 |
The Chief

| Baseball | Cesar Geronimo Master Set | 42.86% |
8.81
|
04.34
|
| 4 |
Phil's Griffey Sr. Master

| Baseball | Ken Griffey Sr. Master Set | 23.87% |
8.88
|
02.60
|
| 3 |
Phil's Gullett Master

| Baseball | Don Gullett Master Set | 40.91% |
8.69
|
04.52
|
| 4 |
Phil's Larkin Basic

| Baseball | Barry Larkin Basic Set | 23.76% |
10.00
|
02.69
|
| 3 |
Phil's Larkin Master

| Baseball | Barry Larkin Master Set | 24.82% |
9.84
|
02.30
|
| 12 |
Little Joe

| Baseball | Joe Morgan Basic Set | 68.75% |
9.14
|
05.71
|
| 4 |
Little Joe

| Baseball | Joe Morgan Master Set | 50.00% |
8.66
|
03.94
|
| 3 |
Phil's Nolan Master
 
| Baseball | Gary Nolan Master Set | 53.57% |
8.54
|
04.76
|
| 4 |
Phil's #24 Basic

| Baseball | Tony Perez Basic Set | 100.00% |
8.86
|
08.86
|
| 2 |
Phil's #24 Master Set

| Baseball | Tony Perez Master Set | 62.25% |
8.56
|
04.90
|
| 30 |
Phil's #20 Basic
| Baseball | Mike Schmidt Basic Set | 63.83% |
9.62
|
05.63
|
| 16 |
Phil's Schmidt Master
 
| Baseball | Mike Schmidt Master Set | 10.61% |
9.21
|
01.34
|
| 13 |
Tom Terrific

| Baseball | Tom Seaver Basic Set | 84.21% |
9.04
|
06.88
|
| 5 |
Tom Terrific
 
| Baseball | Tom Seaver Master Set | 48.83% |
9.00
|
04.29
|
| 16 |
Phil's '71 Pirates
| Baseball | 1971 Topps Pittsburgh Pirates | 93.75% |
| Rank |
16 |
| Weighted GPA |
8.000 |
| % Complete |
93.75% |
| Set Rating |
7.667 |
8.00
|
07.67
|
| 16 |
Big Red Machine '71

| Baseball | 1971 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 94.87% |
8.03
|
07.00
|
| 10 |
Big Red Machine '72

| Baseball | 1972 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 88.89% |
8.92
|
08.13
|
| 11 |
Big Red Machine '73

| Baseball | 1973 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 86.49% |
8.86
|
07.33
|
| 13 |
Big Red Machine '74

| Baseball | 1974 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 94.59% |
8.99
|
08.00
|
| 21 |
Big Red Machine '75

| Baseball | 1975 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 93.10% |
8.97
|
08.13
|
| 5 |
Big Red Machine '76

| Baseball | 1976 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 100.00% |
9.03
|
09.03
|
| 6 |
Big Red Machine '77
| Baseball | 1977 Topps Cincinnati Reds | 96.88% |
9.00
|
08.27
|
| 4 |
Phil's 1970's Reds

| Baseball | 1970-1979 Topps Decade of Reds | 74.85% |
8.85
|
06.77
|
| 7 |
Phil's Dampier Master
| Basketball | Louie Dampier Master Set | 62.50% |
8.40
|
06.46
|
| 7 |
Phil's Issel Master
| Basketball | Dan Issel Master Set | 37.93% |
8.53
|
03.94
|
| 10 |
Phil's Griese Master

| Football | Bob Griese Master Set | 30.61% |
8.54
|
02.83
|
| 9 |
No Names '73
| Football | 1973 Topps Miami Dolphins | 96.00% |
8.92
|
08.45
|
| 8 |
No Names '74

| Football | 1974 Topps Miami Dolphins | 84.00% |
8.93
|
07.62
|