| Rank | Collection | Composite | Completion | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 2 |
OldMaysFan - 2011 Legends of the Hall
 
| 2011 Legends of the Hall | 43.45% |
9.06
|
03.97
|
| 6 |
OldMaysFan - 2012 Legends of the Hall
| 2012 Legends of the Hall | 41.94% |
9.15
|
03.84
|
| 8 |
OldMaysFan-2012 Historical Autographs Art
| 2012 Historic Autographs Perez-Steele Art of Baseball | 12.00% |
9.11
|
01.09
|