Mike's Cy Young Award Collection
| Spec No. | Item | Signers | Grade | Owner's Comments |
| | STEVE BEDROSIAN | | | |
| SR220725 | VIDA BLUE | BLUE, VIDA (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| SR220725 | STEVE CARLTON | CARLTON, STEVE (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | CHRIS CARPENTER | | | |
| | DEAN CHANCE | | | |
| | ROGER CLEMENS | | | |
| | BARTOLO COLON | | | |
| | DAVID CONE | | | |
| | MIKE CUELLAR | | | |
| | MARK DAVIS | | | |
| | JOHN DENNY | | | |
| | R.A. DICKEY | | | |
| | DOUG DRABEK | | | |
| | DON DRYSDALE | | | |
| SR220725 | DENNIS ECKERSLEY | ECKERSLEY, DENNIS (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| SR220725 | ROLLIE FINGERS | FINGERS, ROLLIE (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | MIKE FLANAGAN | | | |
| SR220725 | WHITEY FORD | FORD, WHITEY (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | ERIC GAGNE | | | |
| SR220725 | BOB GIBSON | GIBSON, BOB (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | TOM GLAVINE | | | |
| SR220725 | DWIGHT GOODEN | GOODEN, DWIGHT (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | ZACK GREINKE | | | |
| | RON GUIDRY | | | |
| | ROY HALLADAY | | | |
| | PAT HENTGEN | | | |
| | FELIX HERNANDEZ | | | |
| | WILLIE HERNANDEZ | | | |
| | OREL HERSHISER | | | |
| | LAMARR HOYT | | | |
| | CATFISH HUNTER | | | |
| SR220725 | FERGIE JENKINS | JENKINS, FERGIE (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| SR220725 | RANDY JOHNSON | JOHNSON, RANDY (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | RANDY JONES | | | |
| | CLAYTON KERSHAW | | | |
| SR220725 | SANDY KOUFAX | KOUFAX, SANDY (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | VERN LAW | | | |
| | TIM LINCECUM | | | |
| | JIM LONBORG | | | |
| | SPARKY LYLE | | | |
| SR220725 | GREG MADDUX | MADDUX, GREG (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | MIKE MARSHALL | | | |
| | PEDRO MARTINEZ | | | |
| | MIKE MCCORMICK | | | |
| | JACK MCDOWELL | | | |
| SR220725 | DENNY MCLAIN | McLAIN, DENNY (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | DON NEWCOMBE | | | |
| SR220725 | JIM PALMER | PALMER, JIM (Sweet Spot) | MINT+ 9.5 | |
| | JAKE PEAVY | | | |
| SR220725 | GAYLORD PERRY | PERRY, GAYLORD (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | JIM PERRY | | | |
| | DAVID PRICE | | | |
| | C.C. SABATHIA | | | |
| SR220725 | BRET SABERHAGEN | SABERHAGEN, BRET (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | JOHAN SANTANA | | | |
| SR220725 | TOM SEAVER | SEAVER, TOM (Sweet Spot) | GEM MT 10 | |
| | MIKE SCOTT | | | |
| SR220725 | JOHN SMOLTZ | SMOLTZ, JOHN (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | WARREN SPAHN | | | |
| | STEVE STONE | | | |
| | RICK SUTCLIFFE | | | |
| SR220725 | BRUCE SUTTER | SUTTER, BRUCE (Sweet Spot) | MINT 9 | |
| | BOB TURLEY | | | |
| | FERNANDO VALENZUELA | | | |
| | JUSTIN VERLANDER | | | |
| | FRANK VIOLA | | | |
| | PETE VUCKOVICH | | | |
| | BRANDON WEBB | | | |
| | BOB WELCH | | | |
| | EARLY WYNN | | | |
| | BARRY ZITO | | | |