Even though the volume was not overwhelming, the quality was. The 24 PSA card lots in the Goodwin & Company auction brought tremendous prices. Record prices were paid for several cards including the 1962 Topps Hank Aaron, which brought $9,862 and the 1965 Topps Willie Mays which brought $4,192.

Below is a complete list of prices realized from the sale:

Description
Grade
Prices Realized
1948 Bob Feller
PSA MINT 9
$3,687
1951 Gil Hodges
PSA MINT 9
$4,536
1951 Bowman Hank Bauer
PSA MINT 9

$550

1952 Topps Hoyt Wilhelm
PSA MINT 9
$12,967
1956 Topps Dodgers Team
PSA MINT 9
$5,180
1941 Play Ball George McQuinn
PSA MINT 9
$890
1948 Leaf Lindell
PSA MINT 9
$880
1948 Leaf Gustine
PSA GEM MINT 10
$4,410
1960 Topps McCovey Rookie
PSA MINT 9
$1,760
1962 Topps Musial
PSA MINT 9
$3,000
1962 Topps Gehrig-Ruth
PSA MINT 9
$1,331
1962 Topps Joe Torre
PSA MINT 9
$1,074
1962 Topps Musial 21 Season
PSA MINT 9
$847
1962 Topps Hank Aaron
PSA MINT 9
$9,862
1963 Fleer Koufax
PSA MINT 9
$2,910
1963 Topps Erine Banks
PSA MINT 9
$3,003
1964 Topps Lou Brock
PSA MINT 9
$967
1964 Topps Sox Sockers
PSA MINT 9
$418
1964 Topps Al Kaline
PSA MINT 9
$532
1965 Topps Willie Mays
PSA MINT 9
$4,192
1966 Topps Marichal

PSA MINT 9

$501
1970 Topps Al Kaline

PSA MINT 9

$650
1971 Topps Willie Mays
PSA MINT 9
$5,052
1972 Topps Reggie Jackson
PSA MINT 9
$859
Goodwin and Co. sold a 1965 Topps Willie Mays in PSA MINT 9 for $4,192
Goodwin and Co. sold a 1965 Topps Willie Mays in PSA MINT 9 for $4,192